Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
These are YouTube's auto-generated captions, not a human transcript — expect occasional errors, especially with names and technical terms.
[0:16]
My name is Ralph Avila.
is now exiting.
[0:45]
Morning, I'd like to welcome you to all
to this morning's meeting of the Mohave
[0:48]
County Public Housing
Authority Board of Directors.
[0:52]
Uh
Clerk, would you run us through roll
[0:54]
call, please?
[0:56]
Good morning, Supervisor Breault.
Present. Supervisor Lattman. Present.
[1:00]
Supervisor Martin.
Here.
[1:04]
Supervisor Gould. Here. Chairman
Lingafelter.
[1:08]
Here.
Board member Linda Sadler. Here. And
[1:11]
board member Ralph Avila.
I don't see him on Teams. Um a number
[1:17]
just dropped off, so hopefully he'll
jump back on.
[1:21]
We do have a quorum, though. We do. All
right.
[1:25]
Item number two, discussion possible
action approval of the March 17th, 2025
[1:30]
meeting minutes. Mr. Chair, I move for
approval of the minutes of March 17th.
[1:34]
Supervisor Lattman, do I have a second?
Second.
[1:37]
Heard that motion and second. Any
additional discussion?
[1:40]
Hearing none, all in favor, please say
aye. Aye. All opposed?
[1:44]
Ayes appear to have it, do have it, so
ordered. Thank you. Chairman, Uh could
[1:47]
we do the pledge?
Uh it's not listed on our
[1:52]
our agenda.
>> that, but it's it is a public meeting,
[1:56]
and and personally I'd like to see us do
the pledge.
[2:02]
Um
sure, we can do the pledge. Does anybody
[2:05]
have a
a problem with with doing the pledge?
[2:08]
It's
Would you like to lead us in the Pledge
[2:10]
of Allegiance, Supervisor Martin?
>> Pledge of Allegiance. Absolutely.
[2:17]
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the
United States of America, and to the
[2:22]
republic for which it stands, one nation
under God, indivisible, with liberty and
[2:29]
justice for all.
[2:34]
Um [clears throat] Ralph Avila
is now joining.
[2:40]
Okay, perfect timing. Um
item number three in our agenda this
[2:43]
morning is welking welcoming uh the new
Board of Directors tenant member Ralph
[2:48]
Avila for a four-year term. Yes.
That's correct.
[2:54]
Thank you for
for joining us today, Mr. Avila.
[2:58]
Did we already
Thank you.
[3:02]
Yes, we did.
[3:05]
» [clears throat]
>> Okay, we're moving to item number four,
[3:07]
everyone.
Report from the director, Director
[3:10]
Smith, good morning.
Morning, Chairman Lingafelter, board
[3:13]
members.
>> [clears throat]
[3:15]
» So, I just wanted to uh
I went through most of this stuff
[3:18]
already,
uh but I just wanted to go through it
[3:21]
one more time. Uh
[3:25]
» [clears throat]
>> One of the updates that I had uh
[3:28]
recently was contacted
um by WICOG, and there's some
[3:32]
interesting opportunities where we
um
[3:36]
uh in a partnership, um and that'll be
coming at a later date. We'll be
[3:39]
bringing something back to the board,
but I I did want to share that. That was
[3:42]
an interesting thing that there was some
allocation of resources that possibly
[3:46]
may be able to be directed in Mohave
County for some housing projects and in
[3:50]
working with different developers. Um
additionally, uh within Community
[3:54]
Services Department, uh we have a
meeting scheduled in April,
[3:58]
uh where we're going to bring uh I'm
sorry, May. In in May, where we're going
[4:01]
to bring in uh local contractors, uh
discuss building options and in
[4:06]
different uh capacity, as well as that
relates to the CDBG home grants and the
[4:11]
SSP grants as well.
>> speak up just a little bit, Director
[4:14]
Smith? Thank you.
>> Sure.
[4:16]
» [clears throat]
>> So, in regards to
[4:18]
the the SSP grants, the the special
state project grants and things of that
[4:22]
nature, we'll be bringing contractors to
make sure that they're aware of the
[4:25]
opportunities within Mohave County and
providing that to them as well, as well
[4:29]
as trying to make sure that they're
aware of the
[4:32]
work for Arizona at work, the
opportunities to partner with us in
[4:36]
apprenticeships, as well as other
opportunities uh for for workforce,
[4:40]
right? So, what are those options, as
well as options to be a a county uh
[4:45]
uh uh
a contractor with the with the county as
[4:49]
well, so we can we can do that. So,
those are just a couple little
[4:52]
initiatives that that we have going
within the Community Services
[4:55]
Department. Want to touch on that. Um
and then just really jump into uh the
[5:00]
vouchers. Um I believe at the last
meeting I sta- stated it was it was 247
[5:05]
for for our HCV, it's actually 243.
Uh our veteran uh
[5:10]
tenant base is is 200, mainstream is 115
for a total of 558.
[5:15]
Um we have emergency housing vouchers,
17 active, those will be falling off at
[5:19]
the end of the year. It ends December
31st uh this year.
[5:24]
Uh family self-sufficiency, there's 40
active, and the CDBG program that we
[5:28]
have four contracts there. And that's
all I have for my uh director's report
[5:32]
at this time.
Any questions for Director Smith?
[5:39]
Thank you, Supervisor Gould. Thank you,
Chairman. Um
[5:42]
Director,
uh explain family self-sufficiency
[5:46]
program, or refresh my memory, please.
Sure. So, the family self-sufficiency
[5:50]
program, we can have up to, I believe
it's 50 individuals on that program. Um
[5:55]
I I believe that's the number is 50.
There's a set number that we can have.
[5:59]
And then basically what happens is the
participants come in, and they go
[6:02]
through uh education, right? So, part of
that is is they get uh literacy,
[6:06]
financial literacy, and then they set
goals of how they move through the
[6:09]
program so that they can become
self-sufficient at the end and and
[6:13]
really
uh
[6:16]
it's just a process of going through the
program, but I financial literacy,
[6:19]
things of that. And then I would just
note that through those programs and
[6:22]
those trainings, uh if I didn't touch on
it last time, was that we had uh I
[6:27]
believe we had five success stories uh
that you gradually over the past year
[6:32]
went on and purchased a home.
And that's the same program that would
[6:35]
qualify them for some government
financing incentives on mortgages.
[6:45]
Is that another program? I I believe
that's another program, Chairman.
[6:49]
Chairman.
Supervisor Gould, I believe that's
[6:51]
another Thank you, Director Smith. Mr.
Chair.
[6:53]
» Thank you, Chairman.
Supervisor Lattman, do you have a
[6:55]
question? Director Smith, I had a
question going through administrative
[6:58]
plan, and just a brief one, and
the answer should be brief, too.
[7:03]
The Public Housing Authority, I was just
a little confused on how you determine
[7:08]
eligibility to go on the list on the
waiting list.
[7:12]
And what role did veteran status and
disability play in that? It
[7:16]
there was a lot of material to read, and
that wasn't clear to me. Sure, Chairman
[7:21]
Lingafelter.
Supervisor Lattman.
[7:24]
Uh so,
we we can open the waiting list uh when
[7:28]
the waiting list gets to a certain
number, right? We we need to make sure
[7:31]
that there's people on that list. Uh
after it's open, there are different
[7:34]
priorities uh that are are given uh in
regards to the points uh as well. Uh but
[7:40]
you know what?
What I'm going to do at this time is I'm
[7:42]
going to ask my housing manager to come
up, who actually runs that part of that,
[7:46]
and she can give a detailed explanation
on that as well. Okay?
[7:51]
Um Jamie Bernier is the housing manager.
Thank you.
[7:53]
» Keep this brief,
cuz I know it's I know it's complicated.
[7:57]
Um and we'd be happy to provide
additional detail later on to you,
[8:00]
Supervisor, if
[8:11]
Disability and veteran status is on
there as a list of preferences. They're
[8:15]
categorized in priority um on a number
system. And then there is a breakdown of
[8:19]
that. So, to answer your question, yes,
those are eligible preferences. They
[8:23]
pre-qualify at the time of eligibility,
we do bring them in. We go over that
[8:27]
information, we verify veteran status,
disability status, whatever that
[8:31]
preference identified is, and then from
there we move forward with eligibility.
[8:35]
So, we can provide further information
in an email if you'd like.
[8:38]
» No, that was a good answer. I I guess my
question is uh the list is constructed a
[8:42]
year ago. Um new people go onto the
waiting list, and can they jump over the
[8:48]
people based on their eligibility
status, including veteran and
[8:53]
disability? Can they actually move up
the chart ahead of others who have been
[8:56]
on the waiting list? That wasn't clear
in reading the material.
[9:00]
Uh
to simplify it, they can based on their
[9:04]
preferences changing after they're on
the wait list.
[9:07]
So, if their circumstances, say they
weren't previously homeless, and they do
[9:11]
report to us that they now become
homeless, then their preference will
[9:14]
change, and they will move up higher on
the list.
[9:16]
Okay.
>> common, but it does happen.
[9:19]
Thank you.
Any other questions?
[9:23]
Thank you.
[9:26]
Director Smith, I would have just have
one question for all of these
[9:30]
differing housing vouchers, do we give
preference to those that have
[9:34]
military service?
Chairman Lingafelter, members of the
[9:37]
board, I can say that there's never been
a veteran that's come
[9:40]
to Mohave County and not received, if
they're eligible for the program,
[9:44]
received housing through the through the
Community Services Department. And
[9:48]
you'll see that later on here, there's
another
[9:50]
request for five vouchers as well, so to
make sure that we provide that. So, yes,
[9:54]
the answer is yes.
Any other question?
[10:00]
Right. We'll move to item number five.
Discussion possible action authorize
[10:03]
Mohave County Housing Authority staff to
submit funding application form HUD
[10:08]
52-515
to receive five additional HUD VASH
[10:12]
vouchers which will bring Mohave County
Housing Authority's total allocation to
[10:16]
205. HUD VASH vouchers administered.
Director Smith, you want to give a brief
[10:22]
overview on this? Sure. So, this came to
us a while back and we applied for a
[10:25]
letter of intent to make sure that HUD
gives these to cross the board across
[10:30]
the country.
And if there's a need within the
[10:32]
community, we go ahead and apply. We
submit the letter of intent. We
[10:36]
submitted the letter of intent. They
couldn't tell us how many vouchers would
[10:38]
be available but but said that you know
they would move this forward.
[10:42]
After that they gave us a letter and
said if you'd like to you know
[10:46]
request these and have the opportunity
here. We also worked with our VA
[10:50]
partners and asked them about this as
well. Because the the process really
[10:54]
starts with the VA. So, the when the
veterans identified, they go over to the
[10:57]
VA and then the VA has a counselor case
manager that works through them and then
[11:01]
we facilitate the financial component of
this as well.
[11:05]
Great.
Discussion. Supervisor Wateman, thank
[11:08]
you. I'm going to make a motion to
authorize the Mohave County Housing
[11:12]
Authority staff to submit funding
application form HUD 52-515
[11:17]
to receive five additional HUD VASH
vouchers. Second. With that motion
[11:21]
second, any additional discussion?
Hearing none, all in favor please say I.
[11:26]
I. All opposed? I. I just appear to have
it and do have it. It's ordered.
[11:32]
Item six financial report for the period
April 2025 through March 2026.
[11:38]
Director Smith.
Thank you Chairman member of the boards.
[11:43]
So, [clears throat] here with this here
I would just note that you can see from
[11:46]
the the number of of families assisted
across the board and it really just
[11:51]
breaks it down by city and we also have
Colorado City and then the total for the
[11:55]
county as well. And I'll answer any
questions if there are.
[12:00]
Any questions related to the financial
report?
[12:04]
Otherwise I'd entertain a motion.
[12:08]
Oh, there's no there's no action
required on this. Excuse me.
[12:14]
Item number seven open public hearing.
Questions and comments from the public
[12:18]
pertaining to the Mohave County Housing
Authority. Is there anyone in the
[12:21]
audience wishing to provide public
comments to the Board of Directors at
[12:24]
this time?
[12:29]
Seeing none.
Under the next item.
[12:34]
Right.
Reminder to close the public hearing.
[12:39]
I will close the public hearing on item
number seven. Thank you Attorney Smith.
[12:42]
Attorney Davis, appreciate that. Item
number eight discussion possible action
[12:46]
approval of the Mohave County Housing
Authority
[12:49]
A revisions to Mohave County Housing
Authority's administrative plan summary
[12:53]
of changes listed on exhibit A table of
contents chapters 4, 9, 10 and 16.
[13:01]
Thank you Chairman members of the board.
So, really some of this was was verbage
[13:05]
updates linking the the CFRs HUD forms
just going through it high overview
[13:13]
revise a few sentences for grammar few
things of that nature. The things that I
[13:17]
would would note
uh
[13:19]
would be if we go to page 91 on page 91
is really just limiting informal
[13:24]
hearings to one per family type. That
was one of the things that was a major
[13:29]
change. Additionally
on page 100 families out of compliance
[13:35]
on repayment agreements cannot
effectively move to another unit. So, if
[13:39]
they already have a an issue of paying
we're not going to go ahead and approve
[13:43]
that
to make that happen. And then families
[13:45]
are not eligible of
the next one on page 101 families are
[13:49]
not eligible for a second repayment
agreement for the same period for the
[13:53]
violation. So, those are just a quick
highlights of the changes that we made.
[13:57]
And do you want to provide an update on
the annual PHA plan fiscal year 2026 as
[14:01]
well? There are no current updates on
that at this time.
[14:06]
All right. I'd open it up to the Board
of Directors for discussion. Mr. Chair.
[14:11]
So, I had a question back on page 10-4
about elective moves and I didn't know
[14:16]
you could elect to move once you're on
you're receiving vouchers from the
[14:20]
county and some of the language in this
definitely is constricting that. By the
[14:25]
way, for reference it's on page 10-4.
[14:31]
So, reasons that the MCH policy I
I guess would prohibit an elective move
[14:37]
and it talks about if the family's out
of compliance on a repayment agreement
[14:41]
or owes their current landlord money
or if the family has violated the same
[14:45]
family obligation or program requirement
two or more times in the past 24 months
[14:50]
from the month of request. Does this
happen very often?
[14:56]
» [clears throat]
>> Chairman Lincolnfelter Supervisor
[14:58]
Wateman, this doesn't happen often but
but there are opportunities or these
[15:02]
things do happen for the repayment. I
believe when we when we went through the
[15:07]
process of evaluating the past year of
where we were at I believe it was less
[15:14]
than 5% of of of all the participants
that were on the program where there was
[15:18]
an issue and then a repayment plan was
was worked through. Okay. So, you're
[15:22]
going to block an elective move if
they're behind on their payments. That
[15:26]
would be That's a good idea. I really
like that revision.
[15:29]
» Supervisor Wateman, that is correct.
All I have.
[15:34]
Any other discussion?
[15:38]
Supervisor Wateman. I'll go ahead and
make a recommended motion we approve the
[15:42]
revisions to the Mohave County
Housing Authority administrative plan
[15:46]
table of contents and chapters 4, 9, 10
and 16 as outlined in exhibit A in the
[15:51]
annual Public Housing Authority plan.
Thank you for that. Do I have a second?
[15:55]
» Second. With that motion and second, any
additional discussion?
[15:59]
Hearing none, all in favor please say I.
I. All opposed? I.
[16:04]
I just appear to have it and do have
Item number B annual PHA plan fiscal
[16:07]
year 2026. You just gave did
Do you have anything else to say about
[16:11]
that Director Smith or not? Not at this
time, Chairman. I'd open it up for
[16:13]
discussion or possible motion.
Chairman. Supervisor Wateman.
[16:19]
I'll make a recommended I'll make a
motion adoption of resolution 2026-046
[16:25]
authorizing the submission of the Mohave
County Housing Authority's 2026 annual
[16:30]
plan
the certification of compliance
[16:33]
certification by state or local official
of the Public Housing Authority plans
[16:38]
consistency with the consolidated plan
for the fiscal year 2026
[16:42]
and authorize the Chairman of the Board
of Directors to sign the attached
[16:46]
affirmation aforementioned
certifications. Thank you, sir.
[16:50]
Do I have a second? Second.
Any additional discussion?
[16:54]
Hearing none, all in favor please say I.
I. All opposed? I. I just appear to have
[16:58]
it and do have it. It's ordered. Thank
you, Board.
[17:00]
Discussion possible action adoption of
resolution 2026-046
[17:05]
authorizing submission of Mohave County
Housing Authority's annual PHA plan
[17:10]
PHA certificate of compliance
certificate of the state office of PHA
[17:13]
consistency with the consolidated plan
for fiscal year 2026.
[17:18]
Do you have an update on that? Director
Smith.
[17:23]
There's nothing to be This is just a
typical process. There's nothing to be
[17:27]
updated.
>> Any discussion?
[17:29]
Otherwise I'd entertain a motion.
I think I just made that motion. Oh, I
[17:33]
did. I did. I just Oh, you did you just
did that one. Okay. Yes. It's passed.
[17:38]
We need to go back to 8B then. I don't
know if we
[17:42]
if we uh
approved annual PHA plan.
[17:45]
» not.
So, I'd open it up to
[17:49]
8B annual PHA plan fiscal year 2026 for
motion. Okay. So, Mr. Chair I'll make an
[17:57]
motion for approval of the revisions to
the Mohave County Housing Authority
[18:00]
administrative plan table of contents
and chapters 4, 9, 10 as outlined in
[18:05]
exhibit A.
Second.
[18:08]
Okay.
All in favor please say I. I. I. All
[18:12]
opposed? I. I just appear to have it and
do have it. It's ordered.
[18:15]
Thank you.
Just confused also. Yes.
[18:18]
Um
Call to the public.
[18:22]
Anyone here any have any generalized
comments for the Board of Directors at
[18:25]
this time?
[18:28]
Seeing none, we'll go to announcements.
>> An inquiry?
[18:32]
An inquiry?
Mr. Avilla?
[18:36]
Yes. There's I just like to make an
inquiry on
[18:40]
what was the motion for our last meeting
uh
[18:43]
uh
uh being objected to and we could no
[18:48]
longer can
uh continue with the meeting.
[18:52]
Sir, it was my it was our understanding
that the that the meeting was not
[18:55]
properly noticed and so we had to we had
to
[18:58]
adjourn the meeting
and in order to allow for the proper
[19:02]
time to publicly notice the meeting and
that's why we're meeting today. Okay.
[19:07]
Okay. Thank you.
Thank you.
[19:09]
Any announcements?
[19:13]
Seeing none. That's the last item on our
agenda so we are adjourned.
[19:19]
Thank you.
[19:40]
And Ralph fight