Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
[0:00]
Item 22, fiscal year 2026, 2027
budget discussions,
[0:03]
preliminary five-year capital
improvement plan
[0:06]
and fleet replacement.
[0:10]
So Robin's going to get the
PowerPoint set up.
[0:12]
Perfect.
[0:14]
And nothing like starting after 9:00
on a budget
[0:17]
conversation. You can feel the energy
in the room from
[0:20]
the department heads. Here, everybody
can't wait to get into this.
[0:23]
This just to start while she's
getting it set up.
[0:25]
So this is the traditional start of
the budget process
[0:28]
for us. So we always start with
capital.
[0:34]
And then we bring capital to you
first, and then
[0:36]
in July we come back with the
operating, with all the
[0:39]
departments, the total budget when we
set the Max Millage.
[0:41]
One of the reasons that we do that is
that we don't
[0:43]
have all the revenue sources known
yet at this point.
[0:45]
We do have a preliminary tax roll
information,
[0:48]
but we don't get final until July.
[0:50]
And then state revenues, in addition
to that,
[0:52]
account for a good bit of our
funding.
[0:54]
More than half the general fund
actually comes from other state
[0:56]
revenue sources
[0:58]
and we generally don't know those
until later in July.
[1:01]
But it's important to bring capital
to you. It is the
[1:03]
largest chunk of your budget outside
of your personnel cost.
[1:06]
And it's one where you probably have
the most ability to
[1:09]
to really control and shape your
budget.
[1:11]
So you make decisions on either
construction projects
[1:13]
or large pieces of equipment that are
being bought.
[1:17]
And this this gives you the chance to
do that.
[1:19]
Tonight we're not asking for a vote
or any formal decisions.
[1:22]
It's a presentation of a lot of
information.
[1:25]
And then we'd like you to give us
some feedback and direction
[1:27]
to help us do a better job coming
back in July with
[1:30]
specific recommendations.
[1:31]
You're going to see the CIP presented
in a five-year format,
[1:34]
that is the best practice to do so.
[1:37]
Just like you would want to do at
your house when you're
[1:38]
looking at large-scale purchases and
projects.
[1:42]
What you don't want to do is have a
year where you've got
[1:44]
to change the roof on your house, buy
a new car and have
[1:46]
a kids' wedding in the same year.
[1:49]
Same thing here. You don't want to go
into one of your funds
[1:51]
and have all these huge things.
[1:53]
Having spikes in the budget is a bad
way to do it.
[1:55]
You're trying to keep it smoother.
[1:57]
We haven't really done the best job
of five-year planning
[2:00]
in the past. We with the transition
and finance that
[2:02]
we are going to go down that path
now.
[2:05]
So we're we're in the prior years, if
somebody came up
[2:08]
with a good idea today, they just
throw it into the next
[2:10]
year's budget.
[2:12]
And the discipline of a five- year
plan is you go into out
[2:15]
year number five and work your way
up.
[2:18]
So Council knows through a full
five-year window what your
[2:20]
costs are going to be and what your
projects are going to be
[2:23]
going forward.
[2:25]
And having said that, what's
currently showing in year one,
[2:27]
the fiscal year 2027, which is the
upcoming budget,
[2:31]
is what's funded. The other four
years are planned,
[2:33]
but not actually funded.
[2:36]
And what you're seeing in there are
not formal recommendations.
[2:39]
It's we sat down as a as all the
staff and came up with
[2:41]
these are ideas of what will help the
city run, do better
[2:43]
for the citizens and the community,
[2:44]
but at this point they're not all
recommendations. I can
[2:47]
tell you we don't have enough money
[2:49]
in the general fund based on the
current millage to pay
[2:52]
for all that. So some of those things
are going to have to
[2:54]
get done in later years.
[3:00]
So right now I just wanted you to be
able to see them
[3:02]
and get your thoughts on them.
[3:04]
And then when we come back, we'll
decide what we can and
[3:05]
cannot afford, but at the current
millage we can't get
[3:07]
there.
[3:11]
One of the things, so at the end,
there's a bunch of slides
[3:14]
we go through, typically the way this
works and
[3:17]
go to the next.
[3:18]
So the table of contents shows the
order.
[3:20]
So normally there's a little opening
I give, and then
[3:22]
we go through each one of these
categories with all the
[3:24]
projects in there.
[3:26]
But it's important at the end one of
the things we put is a
[3:29]
summary sheet of all the general fund
project,
[3:31]
because instead of trying to go back
through 14 or 15 slides
[3:33]
and go, can you go back to slide six
and look at that
[3:35]
one thing,
[3:37]
I grouped them all on one slide to
help facilitate the
[3:40]
discussion, because that's really
where the challenge
[3:42]
and the funding is, is the general
fund.
[3:44]
And so you can stop me as I go
through if you've got
[3:46]
questions, but
[3:48]
probably the detailed discussion on
what we might
[3:51]
prioritize and not will be at the end
when I get there.
[3:55]
Moving forward,
[3:58]
I don't. A lot of times people will
spend a whole bunch of
[4:00]
time talking about the economy and
how it affects your budget.
[4:03]
Whether you want to talk about
inflation or or mortgage
[4:05]
interest rates or anything like that.
[4:08]
I just wanted to hit a few key points
here for us tonight.
[4:12]
We know we're nearing build out.
[4:13]
When we had that conversation, even
when I went when I was
[4:15]
hired five years ago, we talked about
the fact that we expect
[4:18]
flattening revenues.
[4:19]
A lot of cities live off of telling
people they didn't raise
[4:21]
their millage rates,
[4:22]
but that's because they're getting a
ton of growth,
[4:24]
and they're living off new
development paying for it.
[4:27]
So you get 16 new apartment
complexes, you got a whole
[4:28]
bunch more money.
[4:30]
You don't have any growth, you don't
have any more money.
[4:33]
So we have not had. And I know we've
heard conversations about
[4:35]
growth, but we have been really low.
[4:37]
In fact, the last, almost 17 to 20
years, we've had
[4:39]
just about 10,000 people total move
here.
[4:41]
So it's like 400 people a year.
[4:44]
That that's close to stagnant growth.
That that is, you know,
[4:48]
fast-moving cities are 2,000 plus
people a year.
[4:52]
400 people a year is not.
[4:54]
But looking back at the trends that
are shown here, the tax
[4:57]
base is the one column.
[5:00]
we used to get double digits.
[5:01]
when I years ago we were when we
would have these meetings with all
[5:04]
the other cities, Port Orange was
routinely in the upper half
[5:06]
of the cities with the most growth
and the most tax-based growth.
[5:09]
That's that's pretty well done now.
[5:11]
You can see that number at 12%.
[5:13]
when we got that high, that was
mostly inflation driven.
[5:16]
Though those were the years when
inflation was like 7 and 8%.
[5:17]
So when we got the property
appraiser's information,
[5:21]
we had as much growth based on an
existing house being taxed at a
[5:23]
higher level than we did from new
development.
[5:27]
But what what it resulted in is if
you look on the far right column,
[5:29]
that's how much extra money we took
going into each budget year to run
[5:33]
the city.
[5:34]
So the higher number there, the first
year at $3 million,
[5:36]
that was the year we we adjusted the
police department's wages.
[5:41]
And so that covered all of that
[5:44]
in that year and then that number has
steadily decreased since then.
[5:46]
And and there's always that
conversation about going to roll
back.
[5:49]
What is the roll back? What is the
percent over roll back the
[5:51]
state law requires you to state that
when you do your budget adoptions?
[5:55]
So last year that one little over
$1.6 million, it was higher than
[5:58]
the year before, was about a 4% over
roll back number.
[6:01]
This year, the preliminary number
came out, $800,000 is all the new
[6:06]
money we have to run the city with.
[6:10]
And that is less than a percent over
roll back.
[6:13]
So you're you're almost at roll back
with with what we've got.
[6:16]
So we have to go into next year with
$800,000 more dollars
[6:18]
to address wage contracts that range
from 4 to 8%, we anticipate
[6:22]
an 8% insurance increase, we have
other contractual obligations
[6:26]
and just general inflationary
impacts.
[6:30]
And that is that is a hard target
right there.
[6:33]
Inflation that dropped down closer to
two, then it went back
[6:35]
up a little bit, then it came down,
then it went back over four
[6:38]
as part of the war, if the war ends,
it may come back down.
[6:42]
I don't think it's going to go
anywhere near the sevens of the past.
[6:44]
But we're we're trying to deal with
funding the general fund
[6:47]
projects with very little new money
going into this year.
[6:51]
So that's that's just an an overall
start to what we're facing.
[6:54]
And before I got into the new ones,
we did want to take a little
[6:59]
bit of time to thank the people who
put together the projects this year.
[7:03]
So we did complete a large number,
over 40 projects.
[7:06]
Now, some of them aren't finished
today, but they'll finish in this
[7:09]
fiscal year.
[7:11]
So a couple of highlight projects in
there, we talked about that
[7:12]
earlier with utilities, that North
Commonwealth water upgrade.
[7:16]
That was we did that whole
Commonwealth area in the last few
[7:19]
years, went from two-inch water pipes
to 6-inch,
[7:22]
now they've got fire hydrants,
they've got better flow, better
[7:24]
safety, better quality water in that
area.
[7:27]
Very big positive project to be done
in that area.
[7:29]
The Jackson project is completed.
[7:33]
Another big positive.
[7:35]
You can see things for parks and
public works has gotten a few
[7:36]
things done as well.
[7:39]
So I'll just
[7:43]
start going through the categories of
this is the showing the five-year
[7:43]
plan on a pie, you can see the total
number on the left.
[7:47]
It's into what would be funded, the
$57 million is what we would
[7:49]
have to fund.
[7:51]
The 284 is all the other years.
[7:53]
So it's it's a little bit more like
the other out years are like
[7:57]
70 or 80 million where this one's $57
million.
[8:00]
The pie is showing you how they're
broken out. Water and waste water
[8:04]
is almost always going to be the
bigger one, just because the utility
[8:07]
is the most expensive thing we have.
[8:10]
This pie though includes the $170
million sewer plan upgrade that
[8:11]
I'll show you later and it also has a
big wedge for the parks bond.
[8:15]
Uh in the future when the parks bond
projects are done and the
[8:19]
utility major upgrade is done, that
the pie itself will shrink.
[8:23]
It won't be a pie of $284 million,
but it'll still be probably similar
[8:26]
ratios.
[8:29]
It will usually be dominated by water
sewer.
[8:32]
So the first category is park bonds
and we did give you the uh
[8:36]
the a hard copy to look at.
[8:38]
For people trying to look on the
monitor, I'd suggest looking at the
[8:41]
higher density ones because the
resolution's better.
[8:44]
The the outer ones are kind of light
and hard to read.
[8:45]
Uh
[8:48]
So on the positive side, the park
staff has done an outstanding job,
[8:49]
the the bond got approved and they
have moved really fast to get these
[8:53]
projects out there to the community.
[8:57]
One of the last things you want to do
is is have the voters agree
[8:59]
to give themselves amenities and tax
themselves
[9:02]
and then take forever to give it to
them.
[9:04]
So Fort Lauderdale is currently
getting beat up pretty bad because
[9:05]
they did a bond about a decade ago
and they haven't even gotten
[9:09]
halfway through their projects.
[9:11]
So so they are moving along as you
can see everything on here but
[9:12]
the Karasi Park expansion and the
trails
[9:15]
is ready for construction in the next
fiscal year.
[9:18]
Uh the Karasi park we don't own the
land yet, so we've got to own
[9:21]
the land, design the park and then go
forward.
[9:23]
And the trails we're holding on
because we're using the TPO project
[9:25]
process where we can leverage some
money from the TPO in order
[9:29]
to get there.
[9:32]
And so when we get that feasibility,
we'll start working
[9:33]
towards some of those projects.
[9:36]
Understanding what's out there for
the public to vote on considering
[9:39]
uh property taxes,
[9:42]
we may want to talk about this as we
go forward throughout the summer
[9:43]
on what we do with request and Karasi
[9:47]
because if you build them, they will
have ongoing operational costs.
[9:49]
They they will the bond will cover
the cost of construction, but there
[9:52]
will be staff, there will be
electricity, there will be mower,
[9:55]
they will be fertilizer.
[10:00]
You know, those projects are going to
cost us money to run
[10:03]
when we move forward, but
congratulations to the staff.
[10:05]
This is one of the most effective
one-year movements of a bunch
[10:08]
of bond projects that I think I've
ever seen in all the bonds I've done.
[10:12]
They're also out there leveraging
with echo funds.
[10:14]
Uh so we we already you've already
authorized us to apply for
[10:17]
echo grants to try to add to it.
[10:19]
So it would give us the ability to
build more than we have.
[10:22]
The idea that they've switched land,
we came up with the idea
[10:24]
to switch land with the schools to
build a park here.
[10:27]
A lot of positives coming out of the
staff to make the most
[10:29]
of that bond.
[10:32]
I'm not going to go through all of
these because you've seen them,
[10:35]
but they're concept plans and where
they're at at this point
[10:36]
and then for each category we also
have a map that helps for
[10:38]
when you're looking at it between now
and then.
[10:41]
The next category, the regular parks
projects. So whether or not
[10:44]
we build bonds or not, we own a bunch
of parks facilities
[10:46]
and they have to be taken care of.
[10:48]
So this is their regular stuff.
[10:50]
Typically, every year, you see them
somewhere between a half a million
[10:52]
and a million dollars of request.
[10:54]
This is probably one of the ones
where I was talking about how we
[10:57]
haven't fully disciplined ourselves
on the five-year budget.
[11:00]
Everything is in year two. So there's
a giant spike in year two.
[11:03]
Normally you'd like to see this a
little more spread out
[11:05]
over a five-year pattern.
[11:07]
but the notable projects coming up in
the funded year would be the
[11:10]
wreck sound barrier, which is being
designed now and then the North
[11:13]
Causeway Park Councilman Green and I
were talking about this
[11:15]
earlier today. It's pretty beat up
over there on the north side.
[11:18]
And that project would come in to to
new improvements in that area.
[11:22]
The Y project is being funded out of
that Rec facilities fund,
[11:25]
so there is basically a savings
account to do improvements
[11:28]
to the Y. That's not a general fund
project.
[11:32]
Parks has got ongoing maintenance.
This is going to be a theme
[11:34]
throughout as well. It was the things
we haven't emphasized,
[11:36]
I don't think enough in the past.
[11:39]
Everything we do, we have to take
care of when we get it.
[11:42]
And so parks isn't always thought of
as that department like
[11:45]
people are used to us paving roads
and fixing sidewalks, but
[11:47]
not necessarily this.
[11:49]
But we own if you look at the bottom,
we have like 32 facilities.
[11:52]
So we probably don't go more than a
year or two without at least
[11:55]
one park being redone or one field
being redone.
[11:58]
So there is a non-stop maintenance
cost as well.
[12:03]
And deferred maintenance comes back
to haunt you. I think the mayor
[12:05]
mentioned that earlier. What happens
if you don't do your job
[12:08]
on maintenance, you pay more for it
later.
[12:10]
So I'll I'll show that with all the
other categories.
[12:14]
Facilities is our buildings that are
non-parks. The the highlight
[12:17]
of our facilities here are the
generator replacements and oddly
[12:21]
enough a couple of things at City
Hall, the air conditioner here
[12:23]
is is kind of junk.
[12:25]
Uh the thermostats don't work. You
have to go up on the roof
[12:27]
and make adjustments up there to
change the temperature.
[12:29]
And you've all can see the high
quality AV system that we have here
[12:32]
from the 1980s.
[12:34]
Uh so those though may end up being
the things you decide not to
[12:37]
do. But it it's there to see we've
had those conversations about what
[12:40]
what's coming up with our facilities.
[12:43]
Ongoing maintenance from the
facilities division, they're also
[12:46]
responsible for making sure all the
parking lots that we have
[12:48]
are paved and taken care of.
[12:51]
Fire doesn't normally have projects
like this.
[12:54]
They they're they're typically fleet,
you see them when we when we replace
[12:57]
fire trucks and and ambulances.
[13:01]
Once in a while you build a station,
what's unique about this year is so
[13:04]
Uh the public utilities department,
we're building their operation
[13:07]
center. We're consolidating three or
four different sets of people
[13:10]
over into one facility by the police
station.
[13:12]
And they will be leaving the building
that they're currently in on the
[13:15]
north side of the public works
property over by Oak Street.
[13:18]
And right now fire trains at the
tower and they train at that
[13:21]
small building up there by the annex.
[13:24]
And the idea had been as part this is
like a long-term out multi-year
[13:27]
project that this was planned, was
fire will then leave that small
[13:30]
building, allow either parks or
public works or somebody
[13:33]
engineering to use that facility and
then they would move over to
[13:36]
this facility and use it for full
training in that one area.
[13:41]
So the request here is to upgrade
that building because it would be
[13:44]
a building used by utilities field
crews to something fire can
[13:47]
train in.
[13:50]
And then the pavilion is basically a
shade structure.
[13:52]
So if you've been out there, I think
all of you've had the chance to go
[13:55]
out there and see the training tower
is not real they're wearing
[13:57]
heavy equipment. There's nowhere to
be in the shade, so it's a
[13:59]
little hot.
[14:01]
So that was the request for that.
[14:03]
And then fire's got a couple out year
capital, we're we're coming up
[14:06]
on having to replace radios in the
future and some of the breathing
[14:08]
apparatus.
[14:11]
Transportation projects are our TPO
funded, uh and good years,
[14:15]
these are 90% money from federal
state funds and 10% hours.
[14:20]
Occasionally some of them are a
little different.
[14:22]
Uh in this upcoming year, the two big
highlights are the Dunlop and
[14:25]
Yorktown bundle. That's construction.
[14:27]
That's why it's a higher number.
[14:30]
That is the total cost down at the
bottom. You'll see the note.
[14:32]
Our cost next year is $1 and a half
million.
[14:35]
And then the Clyde Morris project
will go into design with construction
[14:38]
a couple of years out.
[14:40]
This is pretty well spread out.
[14:42]
Now, some of this because it's not in
our control, we have to follow
[14:44]
the TPO process for the funding, but
it's it's a pretty good job of
[14:47]
spreading out the projects over the
years.
[14:49]
We do get heavy in the outer years
[14:52]
because you you put them in the plans
and one of the things
[14:54]
that's required in order to get fair
share money to get basically
[14:57]
get money from developers when
they're building
[15:00]
to help them pay for it, you have to
have them in your plan.
[15:02]
If you don't put them in the plan,
you're not allowed to get money.
[15:05]
So we show them in here so that that
qualifies.
[15:08]
But we recognize that when you get
out to the out years,
[15:11]
it's not really going to, they may
they may keep moving.
[15:13]
They may show in year five,
[15:14]
but they may stay in year five for
six or seven years.
[15:19]
We go on to maintenance and
transportation.
[15:21]
This shifts over to public works.
[15:23]
So public works handles all this
stuff.
[15:24]
If you look at the funding source,
it's all local option gas tax.
[15:28]
So historically, the city has not
funded
[15:30]
these, this maintenance beyond what
we get out of gas tax.
[15:35]
The gas tax is not sufficient.
[15:37]
To give you an idea that the
everything that we put in this,
[15:40]
if you give that money to public
works on October 1,
[15:42]
they will spend it all well before
the end of the fiscal year.
[15:45]
And not finish everything out there
that needs to get done.
[15:48]
To council's credit, you've asked me
in the past,
[15:50]
well, how much money do you need to
do it right?
[15:52]
And I can't answer that question
[15:53]
because we didn't do asset management
very well in the past.
[15:56]
But when we switched over to Tyler,
[15:58]
we have asset management software
[15:59]
and we are on the way to being able
to answer the question.
[16:02]
We still may not be able to afford
it,
[16:04]
but we can at least give you the
answer of what it would take to catch
up.
[16:07]
Uh, we have it the last couple years,
[16:09]
Council has actually taken some money
out of fund balance
[16:11]
and and supplemented this to allow us
to catch up.
[16:14]
So this is that's the first council
[16:16]
I think that's actually added to
[16:17]
that money to help catch up in that
area.
[16:19]
But our objective is to get you data
[16:22]
on what it will take to be caught up
[16:24]
and take care of those as we go
forward.
[16:26]
I think we've talked about this
before.
[16:27]
The striping budget's like two, two
[16:29]
little areas when you're out of
money.
[16:31]
Paving gets you a couple of roads.
[16:33]
Uh, one of the things that they do
though
[16:34]
is that we don't spend it all,
[16:36]
we have planned up to about 70,
probably about 80%, maybe 85%,
[16:41]
they hold a little bit back till the
summer
[16:43]
in order to pick up an emergency or
something comes up.
[16:45]
because what you don't want to do is
be completely out of money
[16:48]
and unable to fix something that's
bad.
[16:51]
I'm sorry, wait. Let me so you can
grab a quick drink of water
[16:53]
while I interject something.
[16:56]
Um, perhaps on this particular slide
[16:59]
your transportation bond project.
[17:01]
As we update this moving forward
[17:03]
in the project description, if it's
possible,
[17:06]
this is just something that came to
my mind.
[17:09]
If you could put a notation in there
[17:11]
on what the anticipated,
[17:13]
like I know with roadways,
[17:14]
there's an anticipated cost per
linear mile.
[17:17]
Same thing with sidewalks per foot or
something like that.
[17:20]
Just so when we see the number, okay,
$800,000,
[17:23]
well how far is that?
[17:24]
How, you know, how far does that get
us?
[17:26]
So that might be helpful if if that's
possible.
[17:28]
I know TPO talks about that.
[17:31]
Uh, you know, in their meetings and
stuff like that.
[17:33]
I don't know where that number comes
from,
[17:35]
but I know that some of those numbers
for paving and
[17:38]
concrete has gone up.
[17:40]
And they have to have a reduced cost
estimation
[17:42]
because that's how engineers bid the
projects for us.
[17:44]
So and or the contractors bid them
[17:46]
and and we'd be able to say it would
be different
[17:48]
like cost of Herbert Street
[17:49]
is going to be a little cheaper
[17:50]
than than doing something that's a
four lane with a median.
[17:52]
but we can give you those basic
costs.
[17:54]
Just might be a good reference to
have on that slide.
[17:55]
Thank you. Thanks.
[17:59]
The downtown project didn't really
fit a specific category,
[18:02]
so I put it in here separately.
[18:04]
Uh, it was originally envisioned
[18:05]
in the ballpark of $5 million to be
used to be basically funded
[18:08]
when we sold Riverwalk.
[18:10]
So part of the assets of the
Riverwalk sale would pay off debt
[18:12]
to the Town Center CRA,
[18:14]
the other half would would go to
this.
[18:16]
When that project didn't close last
year and we went back,
[18:19]
staff came up with a really good idea
of trying to split it
[18:22]
because they knew we don't have $5
million
[18:23]
just to put into this project.
[18:25]
So what they did is come up with a
phase one idea,
[18:28]
because we've been working with the
business owners down there
[18:30]
and they've been really good partners
and very positive
[18:33]
and they're really hoping for
something to come out of this
[18:34]
to to grow that momentum.
[18:36]
And so the phase one would would
focus on this turn lane,
[18:39]
which is the the road out to
Peninsula
[18:42]
from the south of the bridge,
[18:44]
so it's where the coway comes in the
signalize.
[18:45]
If you've been down there,
[18:47]
basically people down there created
their own
[18:49]
right turn lane in the dirt.
[18:50]
So this would formalize that and put
in a sign.
[18:53]
So it it's a an affordable phase one
[18:55]
that shows goodwill
[18:57]
and progress to the business owners
down there
[18:59]
and probably makes a good safety
impact going forward.
[19:02]
So I thought that was that was very
creative of them when I said,
[19:05]
I don't know that I can go ask for $5
million
[19:07]
and they said, well, how about we do
this instead?
[19:11]
Stormwater projects,
[19:12]
we've got a couple different ways to
look at this,
[19:14]
we we've started off with a stack bar
showing five projects
[19:17]
with the colors are by who where the
funding is coming from.
[19:20]
The the one on the far left is
Cambridge,
[19:22]
that's a hurricane repair from the
damage in the coal.
[19:26]
Uh and and then the other four
[19:28]
are master plan projects that are
coming up in current years.
[19:31]
There there's another large project
Nixon,
[19:34]
that's in out years, you'll see in
one of the other charts,
[19:36]
but it isn't isn't far enough along
to show here.
[19:39]
Uh, this is 62 plus million dollars
worth of drainage projects.
[19:43]
It is incredibly expensive
[19:44]
to go into the old part of town
[19:46]
and retrofit the old part of town to
stop them from flooding.
[19:49]
That's a lot of money.
[19:50]
It's more than twice what we have in
the parks fund for five projects.
[19:54]
So that that's a a a big hit
[19:56]
and we don't have all the money for
the pink part right now.
[20:00]
Uh, you can see the couple grants on
the bottom.
[20:05]
We really hope resilient Florida will
work for us. We're going to continue
trying to transform 386 to see when
their next phase come out.
[20:10]
Brick is a federal program through
FEMA that the current administration
doesn't really like.
[20:15]
So last year, President's office
stopped it, but then a court
reinstated it.
[20:20]
Uh, so I don't really know. They they
were valuable. Fun people got a lot
of good projects out of Brick, but
then the money went away.
[20:26]
So some cities are reluctant to touch
it because you don't you go to all
that effort and then you don't get
the money.
[20:31]
So, I I think it's still worth trying
because it's a it's a pot of money we
need to have.
[20:37]
On this slide, we put it in a pie.
[20:39]
Uh, the reason for this is I think
it's really important.
[20:41]
So it's been less than four years. We
got hit by Ian in September of of
'22.
[20:46]
And in less than four years for $62
million of projects, we have almost
[20:51]
$40 million of other people's money
in less than four years to do these
projects.
[20:56]
And we still have $20 million to
fill.
[20:58]
But $40 million in 10 years is a huge
amount of outside money.
[21:02]
So the the people who go out and get
other people's money to do this have
done a heck of a job.
[21:07]
Because that that's a that is more
than we have in the park bond in four
years they went out and got that from
somebody else's source.
[21:14]
Uh, so again, it's going to require
some work.
[21:16]
We we have the ability to borrow
parts of that and pay debt on it.
[21:20]
If we get to the point where that's a
decision Council wants to, or we can
continue working until we get the
grants to fill it in.
[21:27]
Uh, we I I put them here in the this
is your standard five-year plan
version that we were showing from the
others with the sources.
[21:33]
And then we add this one adds the
Nixon project in there so you can see
it in the out years.
[21:39]
It's a little less expensive because
it tags on to the sugar forest one,
so it's not as much money as that
one.
[21:44]
But this also adds the the generator
at Virginia Monroe,
[21:48]
which is one of the smaller pump
areas we have on the east side of
town
[21:51]
and the two smaller projects you
authorized for design last summer.
[21:55]
The Devon Street one and the sweet
water project are both shown there.
[22:00]
Uh, so that's what's going forward.
[22:02]
And moving on to their ongoing
projects and the maintenance.
[22:05]
Uh, so you can see a couple things
with with drainage pipe.
[22:09]
We've talked about this. It's an
ongoing project to basically replace
all the corrugated metal pipes that
rust and rot
[22:14]
going through that. Uh, they they're
down in the bottom right, it shows
how many miles that we're responsible
for maintaining with that.
[22:20]
On the left side I put in a little
summary of the storm water fund,
[22:24]
so if $160 per dwelling unit, it
generates a little over almost $6.5
million.
[22:30]
The expenses we have exceed that, so
we've been using storm water fund
balance to kind of chip away at those
things.
[22:37]
Uh, that fund balance at $1.7 million
for a this much work is is small,
it's way too small.
[22:42]
Uh, the the point of showing that is
that is that that this fund is not
designed for $62 million of capital
projects.
[22:48]
Two-thirds of it or more than half is
used up by the the people and the
machines
[22:53]
that maintain the stuff that we have.
[22:56]
There's a little bit of money in
there. We're still paying debt on
some old stuff related to the '04
storms.
[23:02]
That debt will eventually retire, but
it's still got like I think it's 2035
when that retires.
[23:07]
And then we have money set aside for
debt service on future.
[23:11]
Uh, and I've probably got some of
this wrong that Sue will have to
correct at some point for me in the
future.
[23:15]
But we've been chipping away at it
using fund balance.
[23:17]
So the the point of that just at the
$160 per dwelling unit, we can't we
can't build $62 million with a
project.
[23:24]
We definitely need other people's
help and we need we we probably
either have to borrow or or find some
other revenue source to build all of
those projects.
[23:34]
Water and sewers, the last of the
major categories of these.
[23:37]
Uh, I we talked about this earlier
when the fee all this is down in the
bottom left corner
[23:41]
is the uh all the the accomplishments
of that that group of people.
[23:45]
To say they have done an outstanding
job of making sure that it costs as
little as possible to give you
high-quality water
[23:51]
and and reliable infrastructure for
water and sewer.
[23:54]
They they do this constantly.
[23:56]
They they're coming in to see me
regularly with ideas about how to do
things better.
[24:00]
Uh the highlights on this budget, uh
the highlights on this budget, uh the
the upcoming $175 plus million sewer
plant upgrade.
[24:07]
That will probably be, it will be the
most expensive project we do, maybe
the most expensive one ever because
who knows what technology when this
thing's out of date
[24:14]
exists, but 170 million is a gigantic
project.
[24:17]
Uh, it is mandated by the federal
government, the treatment standards
are going up. We aren't going to be
able to treat at the level we
currently treat
[24:23]
and we do pretty good. We we send
quite a bit out.
[24:26]
We we do reclaim and that's why we
get credit through the consumption
use permit
[24:31]
because we don't draw as much, we use
reclaim for irrigation.
[24:34]
We have a very good system and we
still have to make it better.
[24:37]
Uh, that number is big.
[24:39]
There are loans out there that are
forgivable.
[24:42]
If you remember we had to do a master
plan before we did this project.
[24:45]
And then we also did the first phase
where we talked about the generators
and redoing the electric and we were
able to get forgivable loans for
portions of that.
[24:52]
So we're going to go after forgivable
loans for this as well.
[24:55]
What we don't get in forgivable loan,
the state revolving loan fund is
really low interest.
[25:00]
like 1 to 2%.
[25:02]
So you're paying mostly principal.
[25:04]
So the fund is healthy enough.
[25:06]
Toby and our financial advisors came
in here when we talked about the fees
last time.
[25:09]
He came in and did two or three
different presentations.
[25:12]
Our debt levels are such that this is
something we can afford.
[25:16]
It's in the system, it's planned for.
[25:17]
and we're going to be able to do
that. But it is a huge project going
forward.
[25:22]
Now that's why we also purchased that
land in the area around it.
[25:26]
because we talked about how that's
going to actually save us money as
well.
[25:28]
Because we're going to be able to
move some of the operation center out
of that,
[25:32]
keep it running up here. That was
another several hundred thousand
dollars of savings
[25:35]
on this project just by acquiring
that additional land.
[25:38]
And then down at the bottom, I should
draw attention to the meters coming
up.
[25:42]
So some people have been around long
enough to remember
[25:44]
the last time we went through a full
meter replacement.
[25:46]
Uh, they're they're reaching the end
of their life.
[25:48]
So we're going to be trading out the
meters coming up in a few years.
[25:50]
Technology's improved quite a bit
since then.
[25:52]
The benefit of that is that these
things have much fewer moving parts.
[25:56]
So they break less and they provide
much more accurate readings.
[25:58]
So you get better revenue because
you're getting more accurate readings
going forward.
[26:03]
Same thing as all the others, they've
got a fairly large ongoing
maintenance
[26:06]
budget as well.
[26:09]
Uh, so you avoid deferred
maintenance.
[26:11]
When I got here, we we've kind of got
picked on for being duct tape
[26:14]
and and uh WD40 kind of maintenance
program.
[26:18]
And we are not doing that now, we are
taking care of our infrastructure.
[26:22]
Uh, and then they have something a
little bit unique.
[26:25]
They do have a lot of capital
requests.
[26:27]
which is one off things like whether
it's a
[26:28]
In this case there's different parts
of the water plant.
[26:30]
So most of these are water plant
parts, whether it's a a pump or
[26:34]
various gearbox units of
[26:36]
that these things are more out of
water.
[26:38]
because the sewer plant's going to
pick up that kind of stuff
[26:40]
when we do the full plant.
[26:41]
So in the upcoming years, you'll see
capital being a lot of water stuff
[26:44]
as we go forward.
[26:49]
And then fleet. So this is a typical
year of fleet. This is replacement.
[26:52]
So all these are things we already
have, it's being paid through by a
fleet
[26:54]
replacement fund.
[26:57]
So as so you buy a truck today for
$50,000.
[27:01]
And then you, the department that
owns the truck, pays.
[27:03]
You think it's got an eight-year
life, so they pay 1/8 of that cost
[27:06]
over the next eight years. So when
the truck's due,
[27:08]
you have the money there for it.
[27:09]
You don't do it at the 50,000 today's
cost, you anticipate the inflation,
[27:13]
so they may be paying 1/8 of $60,000.
[27:17]
So that that fund is there in the
future.
[27:18]
So you're not, this is not new money,
it's it's it's replacing itself
[27:21]
like we do with computers and things
like that.
[27:25]
Uh, so and one of the things that
we're doing is it's not just if you
think
[27:28]
it's going to be eight years, they
don't just replace it at year eight.
[27:31]
So year six, they'll start looking at
the vehicle and go, is it been heavy
use?
[27:33]
Is it light use? Can we get two more
years out of it?
[27:37]
You know, so it it you stretch it as
far as you can to to to where it
[27:40]
doesn't cost more money to keep it
than it does to replace it.
[27:45]
A couple of other things they've done
pretty nice with this is occasionally
[27:48]
we'll have a vehicle.
[27:49]
Like public works had a bucket truck.
[27:51]
And the bucket truck was done for
them.
[27:53]
They they couldn't take it out daily
to get out there and work in the
trees.
[27:56]
But parks was paying people to use
bucket trucks to replace all the
banners
[27:59]
around City Hall and help with the
lights.
[28:02]
So parks was like, we don't you need
to use it weekly or daily,
[28:05]
we can use it four or five times a
year.
[28:07]
So they took the the truck that was
going to be surplus out of public
works,
[28:10]
put it into parks.
[28:12]
And let them use it for a while.
[28:14]
And they show up as a now they're on
one of the new replacements
[28:17]
or new requests because they've
determined by having it
[28:19]
that it's cheaper for them to own the
truck and do it themselves
[28:23]
than us to pay somebody to come in
and do it for us.
[28:26]
But that's the benefit of having
somebody in fleet paying attention to
[28:30]
instead of we just auction this thing
off, can somebody else use it for
[28:32]
a couple of years and figure out
maybe it helps you run your operation
[28:36]
before we buy something going
forward.
[28:40]
Service enhancement.
[28:41]
So this is people basically saying, I
would like to up the level of service
[28:44]
beyond what we have.
[28:47]
So there's an ongoing continuation
budget
[28:49]
which is do what we do now at the
same level, whatever it costs going
forward.
[28:54]
Service enhancements, three
departments have requested more than
what we do now.
[28:59]
Stepping up to something else.
[29:01]
Uh, these are going to be challenges
to find.
[29:03]
Uh I just want to go over them so you
can see them.
[29:06]
Now that'll be part of the
conversation as to what we do with
them going forward.
[29:09]
Starting with parks.
[29:10]
So the out years, we knew that we
were looking at park staff that would
be
[29:13]
necessary to staff all the bond
projects going forward.
[29:17]
As they were looking at how they
maintain the structures and we own 25
different
[29:21]
park structures that are not part of
what's maintained by the engineering
[29:23]
building maintenance team.
[29:27]
Uh, they currently maintain these
buildings through either contracts or
with people
[29:31]
who work there now or working on the
field, go check the toilets or
something.
[29:36]
Uh, their request is to build a parks
maintenance team like like we have
[29:39]
in building maintenance.
[29:41]
I've had a couple conversations with
council members as we were
[29:43]
going over the draft of this.
[29:45]
that maybe there's a value in
creating a unified citywide
maintenance and put
[29:49]
it all under engineering and have
them maintain every single building
[29:52]
and maybe there would be a way to
make this work with fewer total
people.
[29:57]
But but they're they're pointing, I
think all three of these are
[30:00]
valid business request
[30:02]
is that we don't have the people
right now to maintain the parks
[30:04]
building the way they should,
[30:06]
they're not going to get the right
life out of them
[30:07]
the way we're currently maintaining
them.
[30:09]
So we need to do better.
[30:10]
Uh and this was a this was a good
idea from them to start the process
[30:13]
of thinking through how do we
maintain them better.
[30:16]
It came out of our our process
improvements when we started looking
at asset management
[30:21]
and where where are we not getting
things where we want to.
[30:23]
So, I think it was a it was a good
idea whether we whether we go down
that path or not,
[30:27]
we'll see what you think as we talk
about it.
[30:30]
The public works request, so they in
addition to fleet and solid waste,
[30:33]
they have these four key divisions.
[30:36]
This is kind of what they're known
for.
[30:37]
Like this is the go out and take care
of everything we own section.
[30:41]
And when I first got here as a
manager, we had a bunch of vacancies
in public works.
[30:45]
They over 10 people were vacant.
[30:46]
They couldn't staff the four key
divisions,
[30:49]
so we just kind of pushed them
together and then they would hit
projects based on what what was most
important.
[30:55]
But there's a different skill set in
a different skill set in a guy that
can run a a machine like a can get in
there and dredge
[30:59]
versus a mowing guy versus a guy
who's an expert at paving,
[31:03]
versus the people who were good at
climbing in trees and cutting them
down.
[31:06]
So, we have operators at both the
high level, in the middle level,
[31:10]
and we have different types of
machines, and then we also have
maintenance worker levels that don't
operate the machines at the higher
level.
[31:17]
Uh when we started re-staffing and
rebuilding public works after
Christmas this year,
[31:21]
we put them back into their specified
areas,
[31:24]
and what was happening is the storm
water and grounds don't have enough
people to fully get out and do their
job,
[31:29]
so they were having to cannibalize by
grabbing people from streets or signs
and help them out on busy days,
[31:34]
which then gets in the way of these
people doing their job.
[32:37]
Uh so what they've requested is to
these two maintenance workers, which
are pure boots on the ground. These
are their our entry level maintenance
people that get out and help.
[33:46]
With those two people and those two
divisions, you fully staff all four
components of public works
[34:51]
going forward and they don't have to
cannibalize unless there's a really
good reason to do that.
[35:00]
I hope that council meeting doesn't
have a giant zoning hearing on it.
[35:03]
Uh so we can get through it sooner.
[35:04]
If we if if you prefer not to do
that,
[35:07]
or if that meeting we end up talking
about tall fences or zoning,
[35:10]
uh we can we have the 28th as well.
[35:12]
set in there. We wouldn't need to set
Maxge by then
[35:15]
because the trim notices are due in
early August to submit that out.
[35:19]
Uh there's a unique thing with the
budget hearings this year.
[35:22]
There's a statute that requires a
certain amount of days
[35:24]
between when we get the tax money
from the from the appraiser
[35:27]
and when you can hold first reading.
[35:30]
And because the oddity of September
with the first being a Tuesday,
[35:33]
it threw everything out of whack with
Labor Day.
[35:35]
So these are the two dates we are
hoping to get all of you together
[35:39]
to vote on first and second reading.
[35:41]
Uh it doesn't have to be decided
tonight, but feel free to give
[35:44]
any feedback on it if if it doesn't
work.
[35:47]
And then what I said here, we
summarize.
[35:50]
So what I put in here is these are
all the general fund in 27.
[35:54]
Uh so they're not recommendations
from us at this point,
[35:57]
they are good ideas from people that
we want to get your feedback on.
[36:00]
You can see the total over on the
right down at the bottom says total
[36:03]
general fund 5.7 million.
[36:05]
Uh and then the enhancements that hit
the general fund are the
[36:10]
additional 5 1.5, so you're a little
over $7 million
[36:12]
of request in this year that hit the
general fund.
[36:15]
Uh what I put down at the bottom,
when we lowered the reserve to
[36:19]
23 to 28%, we dropped that number to
19 million.
[36:23]
So what happened is we had extra
money in fund balance. Some of it
[36:27]
was from selling Allen Green Center.
[36:29]
Some of it not the main.
[36:33]
And some of it was from FEMA
reimbursements, and then some of it
[36:36]
was the excess funds that was in fund
balance.
[36:38]
So that ended up being your $10
million.
[36:40]
We don't fund general fund capital.
[36:43]
I've worked in cities where you take
a millage rate and part of your
[36:47]
millage is set aside specifically for
general fund capital.
[36:50]
So you will say if our millage is
5.1, five of it runs operating,
[36:54]
0.1 runs capital.
[36:56]
And that way you constantly have
money to you don't end up deferring
[36:58]
maintenance. We've never done that.
[37:00]
Port Orange has always tried to
squeeze it all out of there.
[37:03]
And basically what we did years back
is we just took
[37:06]
leftover money and fund balance and
went, hey,
[37:09]
we got 2.2 million, which one of
these 10 projects do you want to do?
[37:12]
And and that leads to deferred
maintenance.
[37:14]
That's what got us in trouble, that's
why we have duct tape and
[37:17]
and WD40 reputation in the past.
[37:20]
is that there's no reliable funding
source for general fund under that
[37:24]
method.
[37:25]
If you have a year, which if your
mando is a bad year because you get
[37:29]
20 vacancies in the police
department,
[37:30]
it creates a bunch of money in the
general fund to pay for
[37:32]
general fund projects.
[37:34]
So, but he's done an outstanding job
and so has Joe. We don't
[37:37]
have those vacancies.
[37:38]
And even with the turnover, they're
immediately filling them back.
[37:41]
So I don't see us taking that $10
million savings account and
[37:44]
growing it a whole lot.
[37:46]
We have a property off Reed Canal to
sell that maybe get us $750,000.
[37:51]
It's got a pond in the middle. It's
making it a challenge to sell.
[37:54]
Uh we may I think there's a small
piece of FEMA money we don't have
[37:57]
back yet.
[37:59]
But what I don't see that that's not
going to just keep growing.
[38:01]
So if you spent 7.2 million of it,
you're going to have two and a half
[38:04]
left and not a whole lot more coming
in the future.
[38:08]
So I'm pretty sure some of these
things are going to be hard decisions
[38:11]
that we just can't do now.
[38:12]
uh going forward.
[38:14]
But we wanted you to at least see
them and be able to comment on them
[38:16]
before we started making decisions.
[38:18]
And I was the one telling you what
not to do.
[38:20]
Uh but at least we got that out there
so you can you can see that
[38:23]
as a whole.
[38:24]
And then the last slide is the
maintenance.
[38:26]
Cuz I I still want to stress that if
we own it, we need to take
[38:30]
care of it.
[38:31]
We shouldn't have stuff and not take
care of it.
[38:33]
Uh we have seen that with the
generator at the police department
[38:36]
where we lost a decade of used on it.
[38:38]
We've had the the one one wreck got
built, uh nobody added a generator
[38:42]
big enough to actually handle the
additional wreck,
[38:46]
So there there's things like that
roofs that didn't last as long.
[38:49]
Uh we really need to make sure that
we take care of what we have going
[38:51]
forward.
[38:52]
So we don't want to lose the
maintenance as well going forward.
[38:55]
So those are the two key decision
points.
[38:57]
I'd be happy to answer any questions.
I'll look back over here to see what
[39:00]
I got wrong. Staff can correct me
with their corrections text when I
get
[39:04]
stuff wrong.
[39:06]
But other than that, I'm done talking
if you guys have other comments.
[39:11]
Wow. Well, that's uh, that's a lot of
information.
[39:15]
And and as the city manager talked
about, this is kind of a first step
[39:18]
in the annual budget process.
[39:20]
Pay attention, Stan.
[39:22]
[laughter]
[39:23]
And um, I know he's a numbers guy.
He's already over there. He's his
[39:25]
head spinning.
[39:26]
[laughter]
[39:27]
Um, you know, this is this is
[39:31]
without question the most unique
budget session that we're going to
[39:35]
go into since I've been on the
council,
[39:39]
only to probably be surpassed next
possibly next year.
[39:44]
[laughter]
[39:45]
So, uh former Mayor Green used to say
all the time,
[39:49]
it is not about that initial purchase
for buildings, equipment,
[39:53]
or whatever, it will always be about
the maintenance.
[39:57]
That's the cost that really is going
to need to
[40:00]
something and you you wrestle with
and come to terms with
[40:03]
and you and you plan for.
[40:04]
And and and I will
[40:07]
Like I said earlier in the meeting
tonight.
[40:09]
You know, kicking cans and kicking
maintenance
[40:12]
is going to catch you.
[40:14]
It is going to catch you.
[40:16]
and it's probably going to
[40:17]
catch you when you're not
[40:19]
prepared to compensate for it.
[40:21]
Um we've we've we have seen
[40:23]
really important infrastructure
[40:26]
in the past unexpectedly
[40:29]
break, burst, you know, what
[40:31]
whatever, um and you got to
[40:32]
be able to respond to that stuff.
[40:34]
You got to have the funds and you got
to be able to deal with that
[40:37]
and um so kicking the can cost you a
lot more.
[40:40]
All that just to say my my comments
are pretty simple tonight.
[40:44]
I one of the fears that I have and
this probably comes from
[40:47]
not only being a past employee of the
city,
[40:50]
but sitting up here on the city
council.
[40:53]
One of the hardest things that I
think an elected official on this
[40:57]
dais could potentially ever have to
do is cut services
[41:00]
and or cut personnel.
[41:05]
When you know that it's not good for
the community.
[41:09]
But if you don't have a way to pay
for it,
[41:11]
something's going to have to give.
[41:14]
So, um this is this is the city
manager's job,
[41:18]
and this is the staff's job to make
these recommendations to
[41:23]
to forecast for us where we need to
be,
[41:25]
what we're going to need to have to
maintain the quality of life
[41:29]
and the services in the city of Port
Orange that our
[41:31]
residents have come to expect.
[41:33]
Um the reality of it is is that we
know coming November the
[41:36]
residents are going to get an
opportunity to speak as to
[41:39]
whether or not that is still what
they want from us.
[41:45]
Um, so as we work through this year's
budget,
[41:48]
it's going to be very difficult for
us not to have in the
[41:50]
back of our mind that
[41:53]
there is a significant risk that if
we start adding more
[41:56]
new things to this budget
[42:00]
and to what we do as a city, there's
a very strong possibility
[42:06]
that the following year you're going
to have to remove them.
[42:10]
So just keep keep that in mind.
[42:12]
I know that's not anything any of us
want to have to do. Um,
[42:15]
but it will definitely be something
that we will have
[42:18]
to be considering.
[42:20]
So, um I I think that if the city
manager said this is this
[42:23]
is just the first step to lay this
out for us.
[42:26]
I do like the five-year increment
look, when I think that's um
[42:30]
that's the only way to focus and look
at this.
[42:34]
Some of those project numbers are
huge when you set
[42:36]
when you set $170 million.
[42:40]
I'm like, man, I I missed that. I'm
I'm looking back at that.
[42:43]
I'm like, holy that is a $170 million
project.
[42:46]
That's amazing that we're talking
about that.
[42:49]
But here again, you know, that's part
of I guess you would argue
[42:53]
unfunded mandates, right?
[42:56]
These are these are mandates that are
being made upon
[42:59]
municipalities that higher levels of
government to do
[43:01]
where you have to do it.
[43:04]
And it's easy to say, well, we might
get a forgivable loan.
[43:06]
That'd be great.
[43:08]
We're not the only city that are
going to be looking for those
[43:11]
unforgivable loans to meet these
higher level government mandates
[43:14]
and then even if you have like you
said, maybe you just get
[43:17]
an interest and it's favorable at 1%.
[43:20]
That's great.
[43:21]
You still got to pay it back. You got
to have a plan and a
[43:23]
funding mechanism that pays it back.
[43:27]
Um, so anyway, all all that just to
say that that's what's on my mind
[43:32]
Um, is, you know, I I really want to
see us work hard to
[43:35]
continue maintaining what we already
have in this city.
[43:39]
Um, and that in and of itself is a
challenge, not knowing what,
[43:43]
you know, the next whatever four
months may may may dictate to us.
[43:50]
Lance, we'll start with you.
[43:51]
Oh, I'm good. I've been through this
thing already. I rolled
[43:55]
through it several hours last night
and again,
[43:58]
I'm just I'm worried and I'm worried
about what's going to
[44:01]
happen in November, honestly. I'm
just
[44:04]
I'm worried.
[44:06]
So, but other than that, I will we'll
keep progressing with
[44:09]
with what we got.
[44:11]
John?
[44:13]
I want to say thank you very much.
Your presentation was incredibly
[44:18]
very well to understand. I've always
felt like when you talk
[44:23]
to me, I understand what you're
saying.
[44:25]
I hope that our our our citizens can
see this.
[44:31]
And unfortunately, there's 1, 2, 3,
4, 5, 6, 7, 8 in the
[44:34]
audience right now.
[44:37]
The absolute most important thing we
do as an elected
[44:40]
official is this budget.
[44:43]
And no one shows up for it.
[44:45]
It blows my mind that I've had more
people in front of us
[44:49]
for fluoride in our water than the
most important thing
[44:53]
that's paying the operating costs of
this city.
[44:57]
And what it tells me is
[45:00]
that the people trust us.
[45:03]
And they trust us because we provide
the information.
[45:07]
And you did a great job doing that,
and I really appreciate that.
[45:10]
And we need to get this information
out to everybody.
[45:13]
So they understand the importance of
where the money
[45:15]
comes from and what we spend it on.
[45:17]
And it's quality of life.
[45:19]
And it services, it's firefighters
and police
[45:21]
officers and parks and wreck.
[45:23]
Everything everybody wants and why
they live here.
[45:25]
It's the streets, it's the setbacks,
it's the everything,
[45:29]
the trees.
[45:30]
All cost money.
[45:32]
I didn't see anything in here, Robin,
in here, Robin, in reference to the
lights on Taylor Road.
[45:36]
It's all I got.
[45:38]
It needs to be in there.
[45:40]
Tracy.
[45:42]
Wayne, thank you for the five-year
plan, um, and thank you to all your
staff for putting this together.
[45:48]
I know it takes an army of
individuals to do this.
[45:53]
Um, previous budgets over the last
couple of years, me sitting up here
and reviewing,
[46:00]
this was a way easier process.
[46:04]
So, thank you staff for that and
putting this together.
[46:07]
It's always about a five-year plan.
We've we've talked about build out uh
coming and how that's going to affect
the city.
[46:13]
We have to have a plan in in motion,
[46:16]
and by seeing this now come into
fruition, it shows me that you and
your staff is planning for that.
[46:23]
So, thank you because the future's
going to be hard.
[46:27]
November's going to put a kink in
things, I believe.
[46:33]
And that makes it even harder.
[46:34]
But for right now, what this is is if
we go forward, we have a plan in
place
[46:40]
to be able to take care of the
citizens, the infrastructure, but
also the staff.
[46:47]
You know, a lot people don't think
about, you know, you got 500 people
that we we answer to.
[46:55]
But 65,000 people that we definitely
answer to.
[46:58]
So these plans and budgets have to be
spot on.
[47:02]
So, thank you for this.
[47:08]
Yeah, Wayne, I uh, I feel like these
presentations have gotten easier to
digest each year.
[47:14]
And and I appreciate you and and
staff and and staff tonight. I know
it's not fun for y'all to sit here
for a three and a half hour meeting.
[47:21]
Appreciate all the hard work you guys
do,
[47:23]
you know, 24/7. So.
[47:26]
Um, I think Scott said it best.
[47:28]
Yeah, I think we all know, you know,
[47:29]
the elephant in the room with with,
[47:31]
you know, whatever's going to happen
[47:33]
with uh this this voter
[47:34]
opportunity.
[47:37]
Um, with the state suggestions and
and this piece of legislation.
[47:41]
So, it's it's going to be a a very
interesting thing to watch.
[47:45]
I think we have to be very careful,
[47:48]
um, because Scott's right,
[47:50]
the last thing you want to do is
[47:52]
is have to peel back
[47:53]
and and start making cuts.
[47:55]
So, um, you know, there's there's a
time to spend, there's a time to save
and there's there's a time to stand
pat.
[48:02]
And um, this year might be one of
[48:04]
those times that we we want to be
[48:05]
a little more on the cautious side
[48:08]
because um, we don't know what
[48:10]
is going to happen come, you know,
[48:12]
after November.
[48:16]
Wayne, I I think um,
[48:19]
I'm going to give you a a chance
[48:21]
to close out the conversation,
[48:21]
but I think you're going to need
more,
[48:23]
you know, obviously direction from
[48:25]
council, not necessarily tonight.
[48:27]
But I I I think that what I would
[48:30]
encourage and challenge council
[48:32]
to be having the one-on-one
[48:33]
discussions with Wayne and his team
[48:35]
is is provide the direction that
[48:38]
they need from us.
[48:39]
Look at some of these projects
[48:41]
specifically, you know, right right
[48:43]
off the bat for me, the the Parks
[48:45]
and Rec bond projects.
[48:48]
and how quickly and fast do we want
to advance those, knowing they could
get hung out to dry.
[48:54]
And and and that that sucks, for lack
of a better way, because our voters
have already spoke to that.
[49:00]
Mhm. But our our voters won't have
complete control.
[49:03]
The state voters will have complete
control.
[49:05]
And so we, you know, I I've already
[49:08]
talked to Wayne that, you know, no
[49:10]
matter how the vote shakes out,
[49:12]
sometime, and this will come later
[49:14]
after the vote in November,
[49:15]
that we will be able to go in by
precincts and look specifically at
what their our voters say.
[49:22]
So we will do that, you know, we will
be able to do that.
[49:24]
And and so you'll be able to see
[49:26]
obviously whatever happens with the
[49:28]
statewide vote, that's going to
[49:30]
dictate state uh constitutional
[49:31]
changes, or not.
[49:33]
But we'll still be able to look and
see what did our voters want.
[49:36]
And and um, so we'll we'll be doing
that.
[49:38]
All that to say, that's well after
the next budget gets passed. Mhm.
[49:43]
So we've got work to do trying to
[49:45]
to to forecast what we think the
[49:47]
future may hold.
[49:48]
We just need to approach that
[49:50]
with caution.
[49:52]
Um, but but keeping what we do know
[49:54]
about our community is that our
[49:56]
residents look for a high quality
[49:57]
of life and they do expect high
[50:00]
all these services. She's going to
have to figure out how
[50:03]
where that line is exactly and how to
provide that. So
[50:06]
just be be mindful of that. Have
these conversations with Wayne
[50:10]
and his staff and then
[50:13]
Wayne you let us know, hey, I got to
know this.
[50:16]
Where do you guys want to be on this,
you know?
[50:18]
And and I think you can feel it. I
mean,
[50:20]
you know, you're a resident taxpayer
of the City of Port Orange, too.
[50:22]
So yes, you're the city manager, but
you also can see what's going on
[50:26]
right now in our state and our
community. So
[50:28]
just keep us in the loop what you
need.
[50:30]
Any other comments you want to make
on this tonight?
[50:32]
Just to make sure to thank the staff
that dealt with me.
[50:35]
We met twice a day for the last
couple of weeks.
[50:38]
with several meetings going after
5:00.
[50:41]
And Sue and Petra were at a at a
conference learning about the tax
stuff.
[50:45]
And drove all the way over here from
Orlando to do it just to go back
again.
[50:49]
So the staff has been very patient. I
don't know.
[50:51]
We're on revision 30, 35 or
something.
[50:55]
just but all the questions on what is
this, why is this, help me with
[50:59]
that information.
[51:01]
they've been there for the answers.
[51:02]
If you guys if you see a project you
want to know more about, let me know.
[51:05]
If it's something you want to go
physically see, if you want to walk
[51:07]
in the building and look at it.
[51:09]
that it helps understand it. Let us
know what we need to do to help you
[51:12]
understand it, to help with direction
to us going forward.
[51:15]
Yeah, and I Mr. Mayor,
[51:16]
I'd like to just go through every
page one more time.
[51:18]
One more time!
[51:20]
[laughter] said some caffeine.
[51:22]
I know, I know it's getting to be a
late meeting and we're running along.
[51:25]
But I just want to say this to staff.
[51:27]
And I mean this to not only the staff
that's here tonight but your staff,
[51:30]
you know, all the way down.
[51:32]
There is absolutely in my mind
nothing in this presentation tonight
[51:37]
that I look at and go, that's utterly
ridiculous.
[51:41]
So I I I think all of this is
[51:43]
is stuff that is
[51:45]
holds a lot of merit.
[51:46]
It it holds true to what the vision
and the focus of our city and our
[51:50]
residents have looked for and and
asked for.
[51:53]
And so I I appreciate that.
[51:56]
I also appreciate that the staff is
well aware of this discussion we're
[52:00]
trying to beat around the bush a
little bit with.
[52:02]
Because we just don't know what
November's bringing.
[52:04]
And and I know that all of you are
very experienced and very seasoned.
[52:08]
And you understand exactly what we're
trying to say.
[52:12]
We just got to have your way to pay
for it, right?
[52:14]
There has to the the the investors of
our city have to be able to pay
[52:20]
for it. What does that mechanism look
like?
[52:23]
If this is what they want, how does
that occur?
[52:25]
And the complexity of the budget,
[52:28]
thank you for what you do.
[52:30]
The complexity of the budget because
I'm going to promise you this,
[52:33]
Facebook doesn't have a clue how
stuff gets funded in municipal
[52:36]
government.
[52:38]
Not a clue.
[52:39]
I have yet to see one single person,
[52:41]
a lot with opinions, but none of them
have a clue what money comes from
[52:45]
where and what restrictions and
certain money is is is
[52:48]
and how that plays out in municipal
government.
[52:50]
It's it's very complex, so we
appreciate what you guys do.
[52:54]
All right, now from that item, um,
moving on to item 23, Council
[52:58]
Committee reports.