Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
These are YouTube's auto-generated captions, not a human transcript — expect occasional errors, especially with names and technical terms.
[0:00]
We'll, um, do a roll call of the elected
[0:02]
officials. Gary Garrett Patrice Mackey
[0:06]
Craig Christiansen Rachel Whipple
[0:09]
Although this is a public meeting, only
[0:11]
the presenters and those invited by the
[0:12]
council may speak or ask questions,
[0:15]
unless otherwise invited by the chair.
[0:16]
Please wait to speak until called upon
[0:18]
by the council chair. When speaking,
[0:19]
please be sure to use a microphone so
[0:21]
the record is clear and those attending
[0:22]
virtually can hear you. Please also be
[0:25]
sure to limit side conversations as they
[0:26]
interfere with the audio recording. If
[0:28]
you need to have a side conversation,
[0:30]
please step out of the work meeting
[0:31]
room.
[0:32]
It is proposed that we approve the
[0:33]
following minutes: February 10th, 2026
[0:36]
council meeting, April 28th, 2026 work
[0:39]
meeting, and the April 28th, 2026
[0:41]
council meeting. Are there any
[0:43]
objections or requested changes?
[0:46]
All right, seeing no objection, I
[0:47]
declare the minutes approved by
[0:49]
unanimous consent.
[0:51]
We'll go to our first item of business
[0:53]
and it'll be a presentation regarding
[0:54]
the children's mental health services in
[0:56]
Utah County. It'll be presented by
[0:57]
Rebecca Dutson, who's the president and
[0:59]
CEO of the Children's Center in Utah.
[1:04]
Welcome.
[1:08]
Thank you very much, Chair Mackey, and
[1:11]
to all the members and staff who are
[1:12]
here today. We're really proud to have
[1:15]
an opportunity to present to you and
[1:17]
share a little bit of the work of the
[1:20]
Children's Center Utah and how we hope
[1:22]
to be impacting, um, for better, uh, the
[1:25]
mental health of children and families
[1:27]
in Utah County. We're very excited to be
[1:30]
coming and and to be here at your
[1:32]
council meeting today. So, um,
[1:35]
as the chair said, I'm Rebecca Dutson.
[1:37]
I'm our president and CEO.
[1:40]
And I wanted to introduce a colleague
[1:42]
who is with me here today, um, Stephanie
[1:44]
Warner, who is our government relations
[1:47]
manager.
[1:49]
Um,
[1:51]
I would like to begin by telling you
[1:52]
just a little bit about the work of the
[1:54]
Children's Center Utah. And then I would
[1:57]
like to talk about the challenges that
[2:00]
we face in Utah surrounding children's
[2:02]
mental health. And then
[2:05]
some of the work that the Children's
[2:06]
Center Utah is doing in the form of
[2:09]
public-private partnership to help
[2:11]
address the state's needs.
[2:14]
So, to begin, the Children's Center Utah
[2:17]
has been around for going on 63 years.
[2:21]
We were established in 1962
[2:23]
by a woman named Augie Plank. She is a
[2:28]
doctor of psychology.
[2:30]
And she really was ahead of her time
[2:32]
understanding that if we could work with
[2:34]
young children
[2:36]
together with their caregivers and their
[2:37]
families around their mental health and
[2:41]
behavioral health concerns, that we
[2:43]
really could change the trajectory of
[2:45]
their lives giving them the tools that
[2:47]
they need along with their families to
[2:50]
manage their big emotions.
[2:53]
And we have been working in uh the Salt
[2:56]
Lake County area for all of these years.
[2:59]
Now, I'll talk a little bit about our
[3:01]
expansion in just a moment, but first
[3:03]
just to give you a snapshot of the kind
[3:05]
of work that we do.
[3:07]
What we're very well known for is our
[3:11]
direct clinical services to children and
[3:14]
families. So, we are licensed outpatient
[3:18]
mental health center and a licensed day
[3:20]
treatment center for children ages birth
[3:24]
to six.
[3:26]
Our mission of course is to enhance the
[3:29]
emotional well-being of infants,
[3:30]
toddlers, preschoolers, and their
[3:33]
families using evidence-based and
[3:36]
trauma-informed
[3:37]
therapies that are dyadic in nature. So,
[3:41]
we're working together with children and
[3:42]
families. This gives you an idea of the
[3:45]
reach that we have in Salt Lake County
[3:48]
right now. So, we serve approximately
[3:50]
1,000 families per year. Um
[3:54]
the child being the client and then of
[3:56]
course their caregivers joining us. And
[3:59]
you can see, you know, with just a quick
[4:01]
glance at the screen, we have a full
[4:03]
complement of um services that we
[4:06]
provide from the original, you know,
[4:09]
initial mental health assessment that
[4:11]
children receive to further
[4:13]
psychological testing, maybe psychiatric
[4:16]
services, um but primarily the focus is
[4:19]
on that relationship and strengthening
[4:22]
the attachment between the child and
[4:24]
their caregivers.
[4:29]
In addition, we work a lot to help not
[4:34]
only um consult with but train and coach
[4:37]
early childhood providers of all
[4:39]
backgrounds. And that is a statewide
[4:42]
work that we have been doing for several
[4:44]
years now, including teleconsultation
[4:47]
and training. And we offer 100 free
[4:51]
hours of webinars and consultation to
[4:54]
early childhood providers of all
[4:56]
backgrounds. So, it could be a preschool
[4:59]
or a child care provider all the way
[5:01]
through to a licensed mental health
[5:02]
professional, um pediatricians,
[5:05]
whomever might be working with children.
[5:08]
Um that is run by a member of our
[5:10]
psychology team and that is free. And we
[5:14]
have reached uh thousands of providers
[5:16]
throughout the state um since we have
[5:19]
been doing that. It's all virtual and
[5:21]
the idea is so that we can reach into
[5:23]
our very rural areas of the state and
[5:26]
give equal access to providers to help
[5:28]
them better understand early childhood
[5:30]
mental health.
[5:33]
Um we also offer a lot of consultation
[5:36]
and coaching into child care and
[5:38]
preschools throughout the state as well
[5:41]
and we are contracted with the state of
[5:43]
Utah to do that. And so, I know that
[5:47]
we're working with child care providers,
[5:49]
for example, in your area already.
[5:56]
Um
[5:56]
>> [clears throat]
[5:57]
>> These are a couple of specialized
[5:59]
programs that we have. And interestingly
[6:02]
enough, two of the teams on our infant
[6:06]
toddler court program are working right
[6:08]
here in
[6:11]
um Utah County.
[6:12]
Um both with I want to get the um Judge
[6:15]
Peterson and Judge Bezzant in the fourth
[6:18]
district. And this is, you know, working
[6:21]
with the families who are in the welfare
[6:23]
system, in court process. Maybe the
[6:26]
families um are still together with the
[6:29]
child in the home, but the child may be
[6:31]
out of home, for example, in a foster
[6:32]
placement. But this is putting the child
[6:35]
at the center and bringing all of the
[6:37]
services that are needed to support that
[6:39]
child and family. So, that's an example.
[6:43]
And then the trauma program for young
[6:45]
children is to help us reach children
[6:47]
and providers, again, in rural areas who
[6:49]
may not have access to the type of
[6:52]
providers that we have in our more urban
[6:55]
areas. Uh both of these programs are
[6:57]
federally funded.
[7:02]
It's also important to have a strong um
[7:07]
policy
[7:08]
effort within the state when we think
[7:10]
about all the the things that impact
[7:12]
families and their ability to access
[7:14]
services. So, we're really focused on
[7:16]
capacity building
[7:18]
and working to address, for example, the
[7:22]
barriers that families might have if
[7:24]
they're on Medicaid and what codes are
[7:27]
available to help support those
[7:29]
families. So, there are things like that
[7:31]
and and efforts that help us
[7:34]
provide greater access to families to
[7:36]
receive services. Whereas public
[7:38]
awareness is a big component of just
[7:41]
families understanding that mental
[7:44]
health
[7:45]
exists for all of us including children
[7:49]
who are our very youngest and that
[7:51]
services are available, that there's no
[7:54]
shame in asking for help and also that
[7:57]
adults understand this. Um that when we
[8:00]
see children who are really struggling,
[8:03]
um maybe not what we thought we would
[8:04]
see, that it's okay to reach out for
[8:07]
help and there's professional effective
[8:10]
help available. Now, what you're seeing
[8:12]
here is a picture of an annual
[8:14]
conference that we hold that attracts
[8:17]
several hundred providers from
[8:20]
throughout the state each year to
[8:22]
provide training including um not only
[8:25]
licensed mental health professionals and
[8:27]
early childhood providers of all
[8:30]
backgrounds but pediatricians as well.
[8:33]
So they can earn CEUs and CMEs at this
[8:36]
conference and that will be coming up
[8:38]
again in November and we have great um
[8:43]
national presenters who are speaking on
[8:46]
children's behavioral and emotional
[8:48]
health.
[8:51]
I would just also note that
[8:55]
the Children's Center Utah has been
[8:58]
prominent in raising awareness and
[9:01]
providing data for the public to
[9:03]
understand the mental health needs in
[9:05]
our state. So for example, in 2020 we
[9:08]
commissioned an independent study by the
[9:10]
Gardner Institute um which was released
[9:14]
and the first ever study of its kind for
[9:16]
Utah that helped us understand really
[9:19]
what children are facing with their
[9:21]
mental health. And so we'll talk a
[9:23]
little bit about some of those
[9:25]
statistics but we try to be everywhere
[9:28]
that we can be um days on the hill, uh
[9:32]
meeting with our legislators, meeting in
[9:34]
groups like this to help our elected
[9:36]
officials understand the important
[9:38]
services that we have available for
[9:40]
families.
[9:41]
Now, just a quick snapshot of our board,
[9:44]
um we do have representatives from Utah
[9:47]
County as we are working to expand
[9:50]
statewide. Um Senator Balderee joined
[9:53]
our board about a year ago. Um so we're
[9:57]
really thrilled to have the caliber of
[9:59]
people from our various communities who
[10:02]
are committed to helping families access
[10:07]
the important mental health treatment
[10:08]
that's available.
[10:10]
I'll just quickly talk about the need.
[10:13]
You're
[10:14]
probably very aware of these statistics,
[10:16]
but I want to highlight them because
[10:19]
it's so important to understand that in
[10:22]
our state
[10:24]
one in five, so as many as 20% of our
[10:27]
children ages birth to eight will
[10:29]
experience a mental, behavioral,
[10:33]
emotional, or developmental challenge at
[10:35]
some point during that time. With the
[10:38]
population that we have of children,
[10:41]
that's a lot of children who need help.
[10:44]
And that is part of our effort not only
[10:47]
to expand our services statewide in
[10:50]
terms of the direct clinical services
[10:52]
that we're currently providing in Utah
[10:54]
County, but also the efforts that we're
[10:56]
making to reach providers and train them
[10:59]
so that they can better interact with
[11:02]
kids and get them the level of care that
[11:05]
they need.
[11:07]
This is
[11:09]
something that is always alarming to me
[11:11]
no matter how many times I point this
[11:13]
out, but
[11:15]
our children in our state ages 3 to 17,
[11:19]
almost 60% of the children who have a
[11:24]
diagnosis
[11:25]
are not receiving treatment
[11:28]
in Utah.
[11:30]
Now,
[11:31]
uh it's you know, it's challenging to
[11:34]
talk about, but the real realities are
[11:38]
that suicide remains the leading cause
[11:41]
of death among children ages 10 to 17 in
[11:44]
Utah.
[11:46]
And I think that's unacceptable to all
[11:48]
of us. And so, we know that children
[11:51]
before they reach that age have had many
[11:54]
challenges with their mental health long
[11:58]
before they would make that decision.
[12:01]
And so, this is part of the work of the
[12:05]
Children's Center Utah and why we're
[12:07]
trying to do more across the state. Um
[12:11]
we're a state that cares about children,
[12:12]
we care about families, our work is
[12:15]
entirely focused on strengthening the
[12:18]
attachment between the child and their
[12:20]
family so that they have those
[12:22]
protective factors around them to help
[12:23]
them deal with life's challenges and
[12:26]
also experience life's joys to the
[12:29]
fullest. Now, often people will say,
[12:33]
"Why do we have so many children who are
[12:35]
not being treated?" I mean, one of the
[12:38]
challenges you may realize is that we
[12:40]
have fewer behavioral health providers
[12:43]
per 100,000 people than the average
[12:46]
across the rest of the nation, fully 1/3
[12:50]
fewer.
[12:51]
And we have a lot of children. So, just
[12:54]
a lot of things working together um
[12:57]
to to create the need that we do have in
[13:00]
our state.
[13:01]
So, we're very excited about the
[13:04]
public-private partnership that we have
[13:07]
built and continue to strengthen in
[13:09]
order to expand our services throughout
[13:11]
the state. And our first stop moving
[13:13]
outside of Utah County is or excuse me,
[13:17]
out of Salt Lake County is in Utah
[13:19]
County.
[13:20]
Um
[13:20]
and we have done that with support from
[13:23]
the legislature.
[13:25]
Um we've received investments to create
[13:27]
a new hub in Salt Lake from which we'll
[13:30]
expand. And every dollar that has been
[13:35]
invested by the state, we have matched
[13:37]
with private donations, either
[13:39]
one-to-one, and in the case of
[13:42]
the Utah County location, we've matched
[13:45]
those two-to-one.
[13:47]
So, I want to give you a glimpse
[13:50]
into the type of center that families
[13:54]
enter and the feeling that is there from
[13:57]
a team who are experts in their field.
[14:02]
We train people from all across the US
[14:06]
and even outside of the US who come to
[14:08]
learn about infant early childhood
[14:10]
mental health.
[14:12]
And they welcome they're welcomed by our
[14:15]
team into a bright, warm space.
[14:19]
We meet that family where they are and
[14:22]
that child.
[14:23]
Um, we assess them and we provide the
[14:27]
therapeutic treatment that's
[14:28]
evidence-based and trauma-informed that
[14:30]
best meets the challenge that child
[14:33]
might be having. And people often say,
[14:36]
"What are those challenges?"
[14:38]
And
[14:40]
as people stop and reflect, we probably
[14:43]
have experienced it in our own families
[14:46]
or we know families who have.
[14:48]
But is that child withdrawing much more
[14:51]
and staying away
[14:53]
more than typical? Are they having
[14:55]
tantrums that are much more frequent and
[14:58]
lasting longer than are typical? Are
[15:01]
they regressing in their skills? Is
[15:03]
their sleep becoming messed up? Is their
[15:05]
toileting, um, you know, falling apart?
[15:08]
These types of things. Sure. Rebecca, I
[15:11]
just wanted to give you heads-up. We
[15:12]
have like a 2 more minutes.
[15:13]
>> Okay. And then I want to be able to take
[15:15]
a few questions.
[15:16]
>> Yes, so please Okay, great. Very good.
[15:18]
Um, so this just gives you an idea of
[15:20]
what we're hoping to do and I would like
[15:23]
to extend a personal invitation for each
[15:25]
of you to join us at our ribbon cutting,
[15:28]
which will be October 1. This is our
[15:31]
Lehi Center, which will be located on
[15:33]
the Intermountain Primary Children's
[15:35]
Hospital, Larry H. and Gail Miller
[15:37]
Family Campus in Lehi. We'll be
[15:40]
providing the outpatient family therapy,
[15:43]
and also the day treatment, the
[15:44]
therapeutic preschool for children who
[15:46]
need more intensive services. So,
[15:51]
perfect timing,
[15:52]
and happy to ask answer any questions.
[15:55]
>> I do have a question, and this it is on
[15:56]
a sliding scale, correct? So, families
[15:59]
of all Yes, we accept private pay, and
[16:03]
also Medicaid.
[16:05]
Um everything is on a sliding fee scale.
[16:07]
If we are the right place to treat a
[16:10]
child and their family, we do not turn
[16:12]
them away. Okay. Um we do raise funds
[16:16]
privately from the philanthropic sector
[16:18]
to help us meet the needs that cost more
[16:22]
to do the world-class treatment that our
[16:24]
team provides, um than we are
[16:27]
reimbursed.
[16:30]
All right. Any other questions?
[16:33]
It's tremendous.
[16:34]
Very exciting. Um
[16:36]
do you often have children aging out,
[16:38]
and then do you refer them to other
[16:41]
services?
[16:41]
>> other partners. Yeah. Very important
[16:44]
question. In fact, one of the reasons
[16:46]
that we're locating, um right next door
[16:49]
to Primary Children's Hospital, um in
[16:51]
Lehi, you probably recognize they have a
[16:53]
strong focus on behavioral health. We
[16:55]
have the front end of that pipeline. So,
[16:57]
we've got strong partnerships not only
[16:59]
with Intermountain, with Huntsman Mental
[17:01]
Health, with Valley Behavioral, with
[17:03]
Wasatch here in Utah County, and the
[17:06]
referral stream back and forth. So, yes,
[17:09]
um it may be that children have not
[17:12]
received and their family all the
[17:13]
treatment that they need by the time
[17:15]
that they leave our services.
[17:17]
And do you do any court-ordered therapy
[17:20]
or court-involved therapy programs? Um
[17:23]
the some of that is happening through
[17:25]
the infant toddler court program. So,
[17:28]
there is some of that and of course we
[17:30]
do see families who potentially a child
[17:33]
has been in an abusive situation and the
[17:36]
family may be coming into therapy. We
[17:39]
have many children who are in foster
[17:40]
care. So, it kind of runs the the gamut
[17:45]
for the reasons that families come. I
[17:47]
would also just want to, you know,
[17:49]
mention that we all know that mental
[17:51]
health doesn't know socioeconomic
[17:54]
boundaries. Though many mental health
[17:57]
situations are exacerbated by social
[18:00]
determinants of health and and barriers
[18:03]
that face families. So, this this work,
[18:07]
this early intervention,
[18:09]
is so important. It helps address the
[18:12]
complicated
[18:13]
uh histories that families have. It
[18:16]
works both with parents and the child
[18:19]
breaking those cycles that help us get
[18:21]
out of intergenerational poverty and
[18:24]
intergenerational trauma.
[18:26]
Gary Garrett.
[18:28]
First, thank you Rebecca for the
[18:30]
tremendous service you provide for our Valley now. And uh Malia, please
[18:35]
help us get this when we get more
[18:37]
details on our calendar.
[18:39]
Um ref- referring to some of the court
[18:42]
uh services you provide, it made me
[18:44]
think of other organizations,
[18:45]
children-focused organizations in Provo
[18:48]
like the Children's Justice Center. I
[18:50]
assume it's not duplicating services so
[18:53]
much as collaborating with these
[18:55]
existing organizations.
[18:57]
>> and we have spoken with their director.
[19:00]
We're trying to reach and connect with
[19:02]
all. I think that they're actually
[19:04]
coming up for a tour of our facility in
[19:06]
West Valley so that they'll have a
[19:08]
better understanding of the services
[19:10]
that we'll be bringing. So, there is a
[19:12]
lot of effort to coordinate because
[19:14]
there is just not enough of service
[19:17]
providers to go around.
[19:19]
>> Sure. Thank you. Yeah, thank you.
[19:20]
Rebecca, yeah, we Provo is the seat of
[19:23]
the county and we do hold so many
[19:25]
wonderful nonprofits that do great
[19:27]
services here.
[19:29]
But it's nice to see another one that's
[19:30]
not naturally in Provo, but can be a
[19:32]
resource for Provo citizens as well.
[19:35]
Yes. Just want to get that your name out
[19:37]
there so that people know that it's a
[19:38]
resource that they can use. And we'll
[19:39]
put your stuff on our neighborhood in
[19:41]
our neighborhood meetings that people
[19:43]
can pick up the flyer if they want.
[19:44]
>> Okay. Thank you so much. Thank you so
[19:46]
much for your time.
[19:48]
You know how to find us.
[19:50]
We look forward to seeing you in October
[19:52]
and we're even happy to schedule
[19:54]
specific site visit that's just for your
[19:57]
group if you'd like on either the first
[19:58]
or second after the ribbon cutting. So,
[20:00]
thank you so much.
[20:01]
>> Thanks, Rebecca. Thank you.
[20:04]
All right, next we have a resolution
[20:05]
approving the appropriation of
[20:06]
$57,765.50
[20:09]
in the general fund for a contractual
[20:11]
sales tax increment post performance
[20:13]
payment to East Bay Shopping Center.
[20:15]
This is presented by Cody Hill, our
[20:17]
economic development division director.
[20:20]
Cody.
[20:22]
Thank you.
[20:28]
All right, did you get my PowerPoint
[20:29]
that I sent
[20:30]
within an hour or so or an hour and a
[20:32]
half ago? There's some people
[20:35]
that wanted to and I had to all four.
[20:38]
But yeah, Councilwoman Wright, thank you
[20:39]
so much for your time.
[20:41]
We are we have basically four items that
[20:44]
are a little bit cookie cutter. So, we
[20:46]
have basically
[20:46]
>> to read them all through right now?
[20:49]
Sure, if if A resolution approving the
[20:51]
appropriation of $83,851.50
[20:54]
to the general fund for a contractual
[20:55]
sales tax increment post payment to
[20:58]
Parkway Village. And we also have the
[21:01]
same appropriate another appropriation
[21:02]
of $31,003.33
[21:06]
for a contractual sales tax increment
[21:07]
post performance to the shop at
[21:09]
Riverwoods and then we have
[21:11]
an appropriation of $13,509.21
[21:15]
for contractual sales tax increment post
[21:17]
performance payment to Days Market and
[21:19]
Cody will go over all of them. Yeah, I
[21:21]
think that's probably a good way to do
[21:22]
it because they're all very very
[21:23]
similar. So, these four payments have
[21:27]
resolutions dating going back to 2016,
[21:29]
2018, 2018 and 2019. Perfect. Thank you
[21:32]
so much, Kevin. Appreciate you. Um so,
[21:35]
they
[21:36]
have been around for for a little while
[21:38]
and the
[21:40]
I got some feedback from from Kirsten
[21:43]
upstairs who've been, you know, watching
[21:44]
Provo Forward and and
[21:47]
getting some criticism, some comments
[21:49]
and concerns about sales tax increment.
[21:51]
So, I thought I'd just kind of talk
[21:52]
about that briefly since I've got 20
[21:53]
minutes for all four,
[21:55]
but I feel like it's just really just
[21:56]
one discussion with four parts to it.
[21:58]
But, just in speaking in general to
[22:01]
sales tax remittance payments,
[22:03]
I think there's two ways to look at it
[22:06]
or I guess two different
[22:08]
times that it will come to the city.
[22:10]
The first time is someone that's looking
[22:12]
to come here
[22:14]
and set up a business, set up a big box
[22:17]
store, something of that nature and
[22:19]
they're looking for an incentive to help
[22:21]
overcome costs or to improve the store's
[22:24]
facade or whatever the the reasons may
[22:26]
be.
[22:27]
And then the second is if we already
[22:29]
have a
[22:31]
an outlet here that is maybe going
[22:34]
downhill, that is a little bit
[22:37]
past its prime that is looking to make
[22:40]
improvements, make
[22:43]
you know, modifications, expand it,
[22:45]
whatever the reasons may be. And so,
[22:48]
those are kind of the the two categories
[22:50]
that we that we really see it in.
[22:51]
>> These aren't legal anymore, right? These
[22:53]
aren't what? Aren't these not allowed
[22:54]
anymore by the state?
[22:56]
They're not allowed by the state so
[22:58]
they're We're not allowed to do new
[22:59]
ones.
[23:00]
>> Both conditions it would have to be from
[23:01]
a redevelopment agency that no longer
[23:03]
from city to the the end user, the
[23:06]
developer, the outlet, correct?
[23:08]
>> Thank you. And so there there needs to
[23:09]
be that redevelopment agency
[23:11]
um kind of mediating the if that's going
[23:13]
to happen. And so the um some of the
[23:16]
concerns were is is you know, is the
[23:18]
city being extorted?
[23:20]
Um
[23:21]
is is this just you know, businesses
[23:23]
just being greedy and and and what is
[23:25]
Provo doing having you know, having made
[23:27]
these obligations? And there there
[23:30]
really is a significant boost in the
[23:34]
amount of sales tax revenue that the
[23:35]
city has received from all of these. Um
[23:38]
in no ways is it is extortion because
[23:40]
you know, these were already here. We
[23:42]
weren't going to lose lose them. They
[23:44]
weren't going to up and you know,
[23:45]
Riverwoods wasn't going anywhere. Um
[23:48]
and so it it it wasn't extortion. It it
[23:51]
was just basically an opportunity that the city had to support them in in
[23:56]
their desires to expand, remodel,
[23:59]
improve the facade, improve the the
[24:02]
I guess the shopping center for
[24:04]
Riverwoods and for um kind of Parkway
[24:06]
Village as well. And so um
[24:09]
that's a little bit of background
[24:10]
context in in how I take these payments.
[24:13]
>> I think the biggest point is your
[24:14]
approved that a the development such
[24:15]
that we get more sales tax. It brings
[24:17]
more money. It's doing something to get
[24:18]
more money in the end. It's not just
[24:20]
making it prettier just to help them
[24:21]
out. Yeah.
[24:23]
And I also had uh question from from
[24:25]
Becky Paulden about well, it looks like
[24:27]
the caps are are
[24:30]
pretty big. Like the the total amount to
[24:33]
um the max reimbursement 100,000, 1.1
[24:35]
million, 1 million, and 1.5 million. And
[24:38]
it doesn't look like any of these
[24:40]
entities are on schedule to actually
[24:42]
achieve those cap amounts of what
[24:45]
they're able to receive. And I'm I
[24:48]
wasn't here in 2019, 2018. Um so I can't
[24:51]
speak to where they landed on those
[24:53]
caps. Um
[24:55]
it looked like it was about of
[24:58]
a list of qualified improvements that
[25:00]
the city was agreeing to reimburse them
[25:02]
for. And not necessarily we have done
[25:06]
this market study and we anticipate a
[25:08]
growth of this much revenue over this
[25:10]
period of time and if we're tracking
[25:12]
that growth then we will be in line to
[25:15]
reach this cap after 10 or I think
[25:18]
Riverwood's is 15 years.
[25:20]
It looks like it was just basically
[25:22]
tacked to the total amount of the
[25:24]
improvement which
[25:25]
for Provo from Provo City's perspective
[25:28]
not meeting the cap is
[25:30]
good and bad. It's it's it's good in the
[25:32]
sense that we're giving away less of our
[25:33]
tax dollars.
[25:35]
It's bad in the sense that just that
[25:36]
just means that they generated more
[25:38]
revenues that the city that the city has
[25:41]
enjoyed. So,
[25:43]
those are just kind of my setting the
[25:45]
table my thoughts on sales tax increment
[25:47]
from a high level and then also just
[25:49]
speaking to
[25:50]
the reimbursement amount as well.
[25:53]
So, the
[25:55]
payments as you said
[25:57]
are for Days Market 13,509,
[26:00]
Eastbay 57,766,
[26:03]
Parkway Village 83,852,
[26:07]
and for Riverwoods 31,003.
[26:10]
The only curious thing that I
[26:12]
didn't expect and I'm still looking into
[26:14]
is that payment to Eastbay. That was the
[26:16]
only one that really had a drop from
[26:19]
65,000 last year to 57 this year. And so
[26:22]
I've sent the list of businesses that I
[26:24]
captured the the sales tax revenues from
[26:27]
to the representatives at Eastbay and just said hey will you double check
[26:30]
my work, make sure that I'm capturing
[26:32]
everything. As well as there was a
[26:33]
couple of businesses, one had a negative
[26:36]
amount for their sales tax number which
[26:39]
could be they overpaid last year by a
[26:42]
lot and then the state would make that
[26:44]
adjustment.
[26:46]
And then there was another one that just
[26:48]
looked very low. And so
[26:50]
Daniel Follett over in finance is
[26:52]
helping me get to the bottom of of that
[26:54]
one, but the other three looked really
[26:55]
in line as well.
[26:57]
Is Parkway Village where the
[26:59]
neighborhood Walmart is?
[27:00]
>> Yes. Well, they're killing it.
[27:02]
>> Walmart and then
[27:04]
um,
[27:04]
the
[27:05]
>> They're killing it. Yeah, the outpad
[27:06]
retail that they have there.
[27:07]
>> I mean they're by far making a lot more
[27:10]
money than Sandy Springs.
[27:12]
They're making more. Yeah, that's but
[27:14]
that's huge.
[27:15]
>> Right, they that is everything that
[27:16]
>> It's only half of the increment. Yes.
[27:19]
Yeah. So, I mean that there's a big
[27:20]
difference there between
[27:22]
Yeah.
[27:26]
Cuz East Bay's big.
[27:28]
But even so, you look at Day's Market.
[27:30]
Well, yeah, there's more.
[27:32]
>> in the increment cuz I mean that's just
[27:33]
a small store. But East Bay does not
[27:35]
include Sears, but keep that in mind.
[27:37]
Right, it's only a certain Mhm.
[27:41]
number of the properties there. It's not
[27:42]
the entire
[27:44]
east of University.
[27:46]
And Parkway Village is just the strip
[27:48]
mall, it's not the
[27:50]
uh, it's not the outskirt buildings,
[27:51]
right? Or is it the whole thing? It's the Walmart, it is the attached and
[27:56]
then I think there's two detached
[27:58]
outpads. That's what it includes.
[28:00]
There's others.
[28:01]
>> it the Wingstop and the postal place?
[28:03]
>> Yeah, and then there's like the
[28:06]
And then the Twisted Sugar and the
[28:07]
Bahama Bucks.
[28:08]
>> Yeah, exactly. Twisted Sugar and then
[28:09]
the Who just went out of business.
[28:10]
>> Bahama Bucks, that's what it was. That's
[28:11]
what I was thinking before. Yeah.
[28:13]
First Watch, the new one that just
[28:15]
opened. Yeah, that one is That one is
[28:16]
there as well. Yeah. So, But Day's
[28:18]
Market is just the store, not the full
[28:20]
strip. Correct.
[28:22]
Yeah, and so
[28:24]
we would
[28:25]
definitely
[28:26]
anticipate seeing a boost in in Parkway
[28:28]
Village now that the
[28:30]
There's a Pizza by Cafe, but that space
[28:32]
is filled with First Watch. But oh, so
[28:35]
you think that building's included in
[28:37]
this position? Oh, okay. I'll be seeing
[28:40]
it. Yeah, there's offices there are
[28:41]
behind it and other space behind it.
[28:43]
Those are not included, but the Walmart,
[28:46]
the attached outpad, and then the
[28:49]
detached out pad as well. But not the
[28:50]
7-Eleven. No.
[28:53]
Cody, what does base amount mean? Does
[28:55]
Is that the first year payment or So,
[28:58]
that's when they came what the taxes
[28:59]
were before? Yeah, presumably that that
[29:02]
So, that is when they come to us and
[29:03]
they say, "Hey, we want
[29:05]
sales tax increment and in
[29:07]
I see. You know, increment is basically
[29:09]
above
[29:10]
>> in excess of a certain base amount.
[29:12]
>> Exactly. So, when they came to us back
[29:14]
in, you know, 2019 for Day's Market,
[29:16]
they said, "Right now we're we're
[29:17]
bringing in
[29:19]
consistent level of this amount. This
[29:21]
will be our base year. Everything over
[29:22]
that, half of it will go to
[29:25]
And that's just the 1% we collect,
[29:27]
right?
[29:28]
The point of sale, the Yeah, the half
[29:30]
percent.
[29:32]
So, their increase is actually that much
[29:34]
then if you're looking I wasn't really
[29:35]
realize that with that base.
[29:37]
Yeah.
[29:38]
Well, their increase I mean, if that is
[29:40]
the base amount over there at Parkway
[29:41]
Village is 136,000
[29:44]
and now they're bringing in 83, which is
[29:46]
half of the increment. Then again, you
[29:47]
have to adjust that for inflation.
[29:50]
>> Look how much the lower the Riverwood's
[29:52]
is than their base amount.
[29:56]
Well, at Riverwood's
[29:58]
I mean, they wanted what?
[30:01]
A lot more and they're not even going to
[30:02]
be on track to do that. So, it doesn't
[30:04]
look like Riverwood's is as performing
[30:06]
as well as they had hoped
[30:09]
Yeah. But I was looking at this. a jump.
[30:11]
We definitely saw a jump from, you know,
[30:13]
20 24 2025 payment of the 9,000. But
[30:16]
you're saying when they did this, they
[30:17]
were making 118. Their base amount was
[30:19]
118 as opposed These numbers would say
[30:21]
their base is like 60.
[30:25]
Yes.
[30:26]
Well, wait. But they're Are they making
[30:28]
118 plus the 20,000?
[30:31]
>> plus the base. Yeah, it's above the
[30:33]
base. plus 4. Yeah, that Okay, that's
[30:36]
making sense. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's 118
[30:38]
plus 40, right? Because it's think 50%.
[30:41]
>> Exactly. Yeah.
[30:42]
>> So, yes. Parkway is killing it. Okay, I
[30:44]
feel my job. Well, and it or it would be
[30:46]
60 for this year's payment, right, Gary,
[30:48]
instead of 40.
[30:49]
>> Yeah.
[30:50]
For the 2025, yeah. So, I but I love
[30:53]
this format.
[30:55]
No.
[30:58]
But he's he told me that he did the
[31:00]
figures for East Bay, and when you
[31:01]
adjust East Bay for inflation, that's a
[31:03]
40% increase.
[31:06]
Yes. Yeah, that's pretty good. I didn't
[31:08]
ask him to do it. 68% increase from the
[31:10]
first payment to today, and then
[31:11]
adjusting for inflation, that's 67.
[31:14]
So, a 40% increase on East Bay is pretty
[31:16]
good, in my opinion. I just had an
[31:18]
airhead moment. But I love this, Cody,
[31:21]
and I would love to see this continued
[31:22]
forward to have us
[31:24]
just allow us to have the same kind of
[31:25]
format every single time you do a
[31:27]
disbursement. All at once, kind of easy
[31:29]
to compare, to bench test. We never did
[31:31]
get this before, and so
[31:34]
this is just so helpful to me
[31:37]
to be able to see that, and to know that. But even if you want to
[31:42]
throw in, and
[31:43]
this is what it's increased from
[31:44]
inflation, I wouldn't even be upset
[31:46]
about that.
[31:47]
>> add that as well, for the
[31:49]
City Council meeting.
[31:51]
Just put it out there.
[31:52]
>> [laughter]
[31:53]
>> Well, it'd be cool to see how much
[31:54]
they're actually bringing in more than
[31:56]
they did before. Yeah.
[31:58]
Cody, if you go back to 2016, 18, and
[32:01]
19, how did these um
[32:05]
groups become Did the economic
[32:07]
development approach them and say, "If
[32:09]
you'll do a facade upgrade, we'll enter
[32:11]
into this agreement?" Or did they just
[32:13]
learn about this pool and inquire about
[32:16]
it? Or maybe you don't have that
[32:17]
history. I don't have that information.
[32:18]
It could have been actively
[32:21]
economic development approaching them.
[32:22]
More likely, it's it's they were
[32:24]
contemplating you know, improvements and
[32:26]
looking for support from my years of watching Council
[32:29]
meetings,
[32:30]
they tried to find a different owner for
[32:32]
East Bay, cuz East Bay just was not
[32:34]
doing well. And so, that is
[32:37]
what drew them in.
[32:39]
Days Market needed that to help them
[32:42]
remodel.
[32:43]
It was just something and I listened to
[32:45]
George Stewart say, you know, these guys
[32:46]
have been such a staple to our community
[32:49]
for so long. We really do need to give
[32:50]
back.
[32:51]
Parkway Village was for that light
[32:54]
to go back and forth to the old Shopko
[32:56]
complex
[32:58]
that's there on University Parkway and
[33:00]
Riverwood's just needed
[33:02]
some love. Yeah. Okay.
[33:06]
I think it was more Riverwood's kind of
[33:07]
approaching once they saw all this stuff
[33:09]
going on.
[33:13]
Okay.
[33:13]
>> [clears throat]
[33:13]
>> Any other questions or comments or
[33:15]
concerns? I have the
[33:17]
other staff reports kind of if there's
[33:19]
high-level details we want it
[33:22]
I think this is the main takeaway.
[33:24]
Cody, so why is this no longer legal at
[33:27]
the state level?
[33:28]
Different
[33:30]
tools have replaced it or
[33:33]
No, I think I if I'm going to get into
[33:35]
the legislator's heads
[33:37]
then
[33:38]
it's it's
[33:40]
I think it's it's cities getting pitted
[33:42]
against each other by big big box
[33:44]
retail. So, you know, a Costco. We we
[33:46]
saw this in with Costco and, you know,
[33:48]
just south of us when they were saying,
[33:50]
"Hey Springville, what's your best
[33:52]
offer? Spanish, what's your best offer?"
[33:54]
Springville, Costco offered us this
[33:57]
much, can you go above and beyond? And so I think uh just a history of
[34:01]
>> Just to level the playing field a little
[34:03]
bit more.
[34:03]
>> Yeah, just to kind of get rid of that
[34:06]
you know,
[34:08]
we we need this, we want this, we're
[34:10]
going to go as deep in as as, you know,
[34:12]
as far as we can to get this and it
[34:14]
ended up really not being
[34:16]
we're decreasing the the benefit that
[34:18]
the community is getting at the end if we really play that game and and it
[34:22]
gets competitive then then it's I think
[34:25]
it's not unwise for the state to to take
[34:27]
that off the table as a tool
[34:29]
for big box.
[34:30]
>> Okay. Interesting. Thank you. Mhm.
[34:36]
Hey, any other questions for
[34:38]
Cody?
[34:40]
All right, thanks Cody. Thank you.
[34:42]
All right. Well, you just
[34:45]
took us to the end here. We just killed
[34:47]
it.
[34:48]
All right, we are going to have a closed
[34:49]
session. So, the city council will
[34:50]
consider a motion to close meeting.
[34:52]
Gary, if you want to
[34:54]
Yes, thank you. I understand the topic
[34:57]
for discussion is a strategy strategy
[35:00]
session for the sale of real property.
[35:03]
That is a permissible reason under the
[35:05]
statutes.
[35:07]
Okay.
[35:08]
So,
[35:09]
we will take a motion for a closed
[35:12]
[clears throat] session. I move to meet
[35:13]
to go into closed session.
[35:15]
Second. All right, we have a first and
[35:17]
second. Any discussion on the closed
[35:19]
session?
[35:20]
We'll do a vote. Counselor Bobbin? Yes.
[35:23]
Counselor Wetzel? Yes. Counselor
[35:24]
Christiansen?
[35:25]
>> Yes. Counselor McKay? Yes. Counselor
[35:28]
Garrett?
[35:28]
>> Yes.
[35:30]
And we will now recess municipal Provo
[35:33]
council work meeting and reconvene in
[35:34]
the pre-function room for closed
[35:35]
meeting.